10 Best Baby Comforters Reviewed & Rated in 2018

Nothing looks as beautiful or comfortable as a fluffy soft comforter on a baby crib or bed. Matched with the cute little sheets and bed skirts, they truly set off the whole nursery in a delightful décor. We feature in this informative buying guide the best-rated and most-reviewed baby comforters online by satisfied customers who love these excellent selections. The designs and patterns are gorgeous and fitting for both girl and boy infants. The beautiful designs include Disney’s princesses, a plush teddy bear, cute woodland critters, Disney’s princesses, and fun safari animals. Most of these covers are dual-sided, so they are versatile with the bedding and room colors. Some of them have a quilt design and one is hand-sewn of little squares in various fabrics. We even highlight a white comforter that is filled with goose down and as soft and puffy as a dreamy cloud. Four of these great products are sets that include the soft comforter, a durable fitted sheet, and a frilly bed skirt in a remarkable matching pattern. These are all so wonderful that it will be very difficult for parents to choose the perfect one for their child. If you need a gift for new or soon-to-be parents, there is no better present than one of these marvelous comforters. Manufacturers have created some stunning covers to comfort and snuggle with your baby that you will love also. We are excited to showcase them here for your enhanced shopping experience. Here are the best baby comforters in 2018.

10 Best Baby Comforters Reviewed

 

1. American Baby Company 100% Cotton

1. American Baby Company 100% Cotton
Having the most reviews online and one of the highest rating from customers, this bedding set is tops with parents and children. Available in eight terrific colors and suitable for both girls and boys, this four-piece bedding set from the American Baby Company is a ready-made ideal product.
Expand to see more
It is a four-piece bed set that includes a warm comforter, a fitted and a regular bottom sheet, and a soft pillowcase of standard size. This fabulous ensemble can be machine washed and is practical and durable cotton material. The comforter is double-sided for versatility in decorating the bed. This great bedding set is from a trusted manufacturer devoted to product value and quality. The top sheet is a solid color that matches one side of the comforter, and the fitted sheet has the beautiful pattern of the underside of the cover. The lovely pillowcase is the same pretty color of the cover underside. Because of the many color choices and the many pieces in the set, this would make an ideal gift for new parents.

Benefits
Being that this is a complete bedding assortment, you will not have to buy anything for the bed separately. It is trouble and hassle-free for busy parents who need shopping simplicity.

What We Like About It
Each piece of this incredible set matches so well with the others. The sheets each match one side of the cover and the pillowcase is the solid color of the comforter. This terrific set will instantly add a splash of color to the nursery or child’s room.

Cost and Value
With a below-average cost, this wonderful item derives its great value from the double-sided comforter, extra accessory pieces, and the gorgeous matching colors throughout the set.
Pros

Available in eight terrific colors

Suitable for both girls and boys

Includes a comforter, sheets, and a pillowcase

Can be machine washed

Comforter is double-sided

Cons

Some parents said the fitted sheet is too small for their crib mattresses

Comforter may pill after washing a few times

2. Nojo 3-Piece Safari Kids

2. Nojo 3-Piece Safari Kids
The Safari Kids 3-Piece Comforter Set by Nojo has a cute colorful background on the cover in yellow and green, so it is gender-neutral and perfect for gift-giving. This three-piece set is made of soft comfortable cotton and polyester materials and can be machine washed and dried.
Expand to see more
It includes the soft comforter, a frilly crib skirt, and a cozy fitted sheet. The superb comforter has cartoon graphics of a giraffe, monkey, elephant, lion, and zebras on the top side of the comforter for kids to play with and enjoy.

Benefits
The adorable zoo animals on this incredible cover are not just cute, they can also be educational in teaching some of the well-known animals. Toddlers can easily learn the names and colors of the popular creatures depicted.

What We Like About It
It is fabulous when makers of baby items create them in colors that are suitable for both boys and girls. This way, if you want to give it as a gift and do not know the sex of the baby, it is okay and appropriate.

Cost and Value
Costing below the average price, this wonderful animal bedding set has the terrific features of being a multiple unit assortment, containing cute fun animals, and having unisex colors throughout.
Pros

Made of cotton and polyester

Can be machine washed and dried

Features a cover in unisex colors

includes a comforter, a sheet, and a bed skirt

Has the cartoon graphics of five various animals

Cons

Some buyers said the comforter pills after being washed

Was thinner than some people expected

3. Disney Dumbo 3 Piece Crib

3. Disney Dumbo 3 Piece Crib
Offered in eight various color schemes, the Disney Dumbo 3-Piece Crib Bedding Set is a bright and colorful combination. It features Disney’s popular lovable Dumbo the elephant character.
Expand to see more
This superb three-piece set is made of polyester microfiber and filled with fiberfill of polyester. It can be machine washed and dried, plus it includes the great pieces of the vivid comforter, a cute dust ruffle, and a comfortable fitted sheet. This wonderful product is beautifully decorated with appliques of Dumbo, stars, flags, and striped balls.

Benefits
You get a completely furnished crib bed with this amazing colorful assortment. Nothing else needs to be purchased for the lucky little child who gets this as a gift or everyday surprise.

What We Like About It
All kids love Disney’s Dumbo and love to have everything with his image. This lovely bedding set will quickly become a family heirloom that your child will treasure for many years.

Cost and Value
This fantastic comforter set has an average price. It derives its value from being a three-piece set perfect for the crib, having fun appliques of Dumbo, and available in many color choices.
Pros

Made of polyester microfiber and fiberfill

Features Disney’s lovable Dumbo

Can be machine washed and dried

Includes the comforter, a dust ruffle, and a fitted sheet

Beautifully decorated with appliques

Cons

Colors were not as bright as some people expected

The size was too big said a couple of buyers

4. Tadpoles Toddler Teddy Pattern/White

4. Tadpoles Toddler Teddy Pattern/White
The Tadpoles Toddler Comforter is warm, puffy, comfortable, and breathable. It features the pattern of a cute simple teddy bear sewn into the comforter and is made of a 100% microfiber brushed super-soft polyester shell.
Expand to see more
This fantastic cover can be machine washed and dried and is a pretty solid white color. Ideal size for babies’ and toddlers’ beds, this charming comforter will add that perfect touch to your child’s room and be a favorite they will want to snuggle with each night.

Benefits
Besides being warm, baby comforters should be very comfortable too. This one has both of these ideal features to make your baby so happy and snug in their crib or bed.

What We Like About It
When you just want a simple design on your baby’s bed, then this sweet white teddy bear comforter is perfect. It will go with any other sheets, covers, and pillows that you may already have in place.

Cost and Value
This splendid product has the lowest cost out of all items on this comforter list. It has the terrific qualities of being a solid neutral color, having a simple design that will go with any décor and bed set, and being super-soft and puffy.
Pros

Is warm, puffy, comfortable, and breathable

Features a cute simple teddy bear

Made of 100% super-soft polyester

Can be machine washed and dried

Ideal size for babies and toddlers’ beds

Cons

Filling can pile up in spots after washing

Was bigger than some people expected

5. Burt's Bees Baby Reversible Quilt

5. Burt's Bees Baby Reversible Quilt
This incredible comforter is double-sided with a nice solid color on one side and a checkered pattern on the other. The colors are two shades of interesting gray and white.
Made of 100% pure organic super-soft jersey cotton knit, it is comfortable, breathable, and warm.
Expand to see more
It is processed in an extra step of combing to make it very soft, plus this terrific comforter gets softer and cozier after every washing. This ideal product is organic, hypoallergenic, and will not irritate sensitive skin. Certified by a third-party for not having chemicals or pesticides in the manufacturing or growing process. This Burt’s Bees item can be machine washed and dried, and it will stay in place and not move because of the durable sewing points.

Benefits
Because this fabulous cover has two sides that are great for displaying, you can change the décor of the child’s room every now and then. It adds versatility to their bedclothes and also their interest in their own belongings.

What We Like About It
The filling moving in comforters is a common problem, even for adult products. This one has plenty of stitch points to keep the stuffing where it should be, so it will not pile up in one corner as others do.

Cost and Value
With an above-average cost, this lovely quilt has the wonderful features of a dual pattern, being pure organic cotton, and having a filling that will stay in place after multiple washings.
Pros

Made of 100% pure organic super-soft cotton

Comfortable, breathable, and warm

Organic and hypoallergenic

Gets softer and cozier after every washing

Fill will stay in place and not move

Cons

Some buyers experience pilling of this item after washing

Product may shrink in size a bit after initial wash

6. Warm Things White Down

6. Warm Things White Down
The Just for Baby White Down Comforter is hypoallergenic and made of cotton material. It is filled with fluffy goose down making it thick, soft, and comfortable. This superb product features a construction of baffles channel and fits a standard-sized crib perfectly.
Expand to see more
It is a simple design that will match other bedding items and room décor, plus it is light but very warm in winter and cooler in warm months. Everyone who has ever had a good down pillow or comforter knows that they are truly wonderful and kept in the family to hand down to others. down-filled items are the softest, warmest, and fluffiest covers that will ever experience.

Benefits
Both babies and toddlers will have many years of use from this excellent product. It is large enough to fit a standard-sized crib and can be used well into the later toddler years.

What We Like About It
Whether the weather is warm or cool, your child will be so comfortable under this down comforter. The light feathers are known for being appropriate to any temperature anywhere.

Cost and Value
This is the most expensive item we feature. This is obviously because it is filled with real goose feathers for the filling. It is also hypoallergenic, thick, fluffy, and pure white similar to a soft cloud.
Pros

Is hypoallergenic and soft

Features a construction of baffles channel

Made of cotton and filled with goose down

Is a simple and will match other bedding items

Is light but very warm in winter

Cons

Some comforters did not have much down in them

A few people experienced some of the feathers coming out

7. Lolli Living Enchaned Garden Quilted

7. Lolli Living Enchaned Garden Quilted
Featuring rabbits, owls, squirrels, deer, leaves, and trees, the Lolli Living Quilted Comforter has pastel shades of gray and pink and a woodland design. It is double-sided with pictures on one side and a pink and white fan pattern on the other.
Expand to see more
Made of 100% cotton material, this terrific cover has a pom-pom trim and is lightly padded, soft, and cozy. This super-soft comforter will become a family treasure to hand down from child to child because of the comfort and cute design.

Benefits
This is another comforter that is as educational as it is warm and comfortable. Toddlers will be able to point out and name all of the little forest creatures depicted on this wonderful cover.

What We Like About It
You can use this fabulous comforter two ways because of the dual sides. One has the pretty design of the woodland animals scattered about and the other has a pretty fan design.

Cost and Value
Priced above the average of this group of comforters, this one has the fantastic qualities of a beautiful pattern of forest animals, lovely pastel shades, and a delicate pom-pom trim on the edge.
Pros

Features many favored animals

Is double-sided with pictures and a fan pattern

Made of 100% cotton material

Includes a pom-pom trim

Lightly padded, soft, and cozy

Cons

May be smaller than expected

Some were disappointed with the feel and softness

8. RAJRANG Light Grey Fish Pattern

8. RAJRANG Light Grey Fish Pattern
Featuring a cute pattern of pink and grey whales, this Soft Cot Comforter is made of soft and durable cotton material. It has several fabric patterns of pictures, dots, and checkered squares in a beautiful handmade quilt design.
Expand to see more
This is an ideal size for most cribs and toddler beds and will not irritate sensitive skin. Offered in five colors, this lovely comforter is hypoallergenic and free of lead, BPA, and latex. The fabric is lightweight, breathable, and soft and gets softer with every wash.

Benefits
You want only the best for your child, especially in their crib or bed. The fabrics there are the ones that touch them every day. This cute comforter is made of pure cotton and is so soft.

What We Like About It
Handmade quilts are a true treasure to own in the family. This one for babies will surely become a gift that will be passed down from child to child. It has several various fabric squares handsewn.

Cost and Value
With a below-average cost, this adorable quilt for babies is handmade, has a cute pattern and multiple fabric squares, and is hypoallergenic and made of pure cotton.
Pros

Is a beautiful handmade quilt

Made of soft pure cotton material

Is an ideal size for cribs and toddler beds

Hypoallergenic and free of lead, BPA, and latex

Gets softer with every wash

Cons

May be thin according to some people

Maker said it must be dry cleaned

9. NoJo Little Love Anchor Applique

9. NoJo Little Love Anchor Applique
Made of cotton and polyester materials, the Little Love Anchor Applique Comforter has a polyester filling and is perfect for little boys of infant and toddler ages. It can be machine washed and dried and is a very soft yet firm cover you will love to have for your child.
Expand to see more
This superb comforter has double sides with an adorable anchor applique on the top of the two-tone blue design and a lovely chevron pattern of navy and white on the back. This would make the perfect baby shower gift for new parents.

Benefits
For babies, you want a cover that is soft but still firm enough to be warm and weighted to stay in place over the baby. This one is perfect because it is firm with a nice soft feel.

What We Like About It
Baby covers that have two decorative sides are wonderful for versatility in the room or nursery décor. This gives you many options when matching sheets, pillowcases, and pillows for the infant.

Cost and Value
Having a below-average price, this cute comforter for boys has the great qualities of being double-sided, machine-washable, and made of high-quality polyester and cotton materials.
Pros

Made of cotton and polyester

Has a fluffy polyester filling

Can be machine washed and dried

Is double-sided with an adorable anchor applique

Is a very soft yet firm cover

Cons

A few buyers said it thinner than expected

May fade or pill after several washings

10. Disney Princess 3-Piece Happily Ever After

10. Disney Princess 3-Piece Happily Ever After
The Disney Princess 3-Piece Comforter Set has a Disney princess theme and fits a standard baby crib perfectly. It is a bed set of three pieces including the fluffy soft comforter, a pretty dust ruffle, and a cozy fitted sheet.
Expand to see more
The cover is made of durable polyester and satin materials and the long-lasting sheet is cotton and polyester. This great set can be machine washed and dried for the best care and longevity of the product. Make your child’s crib look like the bed of a Disney princess quickly and easily with this amazing comforter assortment.

Benefits
The Disney princesses are a favorite of little girls of all ages. As soon as kids can watch the cartoons, they attach to the loveable characters and want to have things with their images. This adorable princess bed set will be a huge hit in your home.

What We Like About It
You will not need to purchase anything else besides this set for your child’s crib, as it comes with everything needed for a cozy slumber. Bed sets are great to ensure that all pieces match well.

Cost and Value
This terrific item is above the calculated average because it is a crib bed set and not just the cover. You get the cover, a sheet, and a dust ruffle to fit a standard-sized crib in style for your little girl.
Pros

Has a Disney princess theme

Is a bed set of three pieces

Fits a baby crib of standard size perfectly

Made of polyester and satin

Can be machine washed and dried

Cons

Fabric may be too silky

A few buyers had fraying at the seams when received

Criteria Used in Evaluation of the Best Baby Comforters

Top-rated and most-reviewed

We choose only the best products for any of our informative buying guides to only showcase the top items available online for you. These fabulous baby comforters have the best-ratings and the most reviews out of all items in this category. They overwhelmingly please customers with their excellence and superiority. They would purchase them again if they needed them again. in our summary sections, we give you all of the details that we have researched. The details from manufacturer’s product descriptions and feedback from consumers are included there. The baby comforter with the most reviews is the American Baby Company 4-Piece Toddler Bedding Set. There is a two-way tie for the cover with the best rating. These are the Just for Baby White Down Comforter and the American Baby Company 4—Piece Toddler Bedding Set. Customers really loved these and gave them very high ratings.

Made just for a baby

Each of these delightful covers has a pattern or design that is perfect for a baby crib or toddler bed. The colors are delicate pastels or as colorful as a rainbow. There are safari animals, woodland critters, a cute teddy bear, Disney Princesses, and Disney’s famed Dumbo on these wonderful comforters for babies. The others have gorgeous patterns that will go well with most room and bedding décors. The sizes are perfect for a standard-sized crib or toddler bed. They can be used for many years, even when the child outgrows them as a cover. Bundle them up to be a nice soft pillow or cushion to rest on. Kids will treasure these for many years as a secure childhood item.

Comfortable and durable fabrics

Made of the softest cotton and polyester materials, all of these products are cozy, warm, and comfortable for the child. they are filled with polyester and one is stuffed with goose feathers for a lovely down comforter. This item is lighter than a regular cover because of the light feathers it contains. This disappointed some buyers because it did not seem filled enough to them. However, items filled with goose down must not be packed in and should stay loose inside. That is the magic of using goose feathers for warmth and comfort. Whatever the weather, the child will stay cool in warm weather and warm in warm environments. Some of the featured items are quilts that are excellently stitched. These can be handed down to other children int eh family or kept as family heirlooms to treasure for years.

Easy to care for and use

These terrific covers can all be machine washed and dried easily. One must be dry cleaned, though. Even the sets are simple to use and place on the bed or crib. Just place the bed skirt on and the sheets on the mattress. The comforter can be used alone or with other covers on the bed. Most of them have double-sides that are perfect for either side to be on top. As you change the décor or style of the room and bed, these comforters are more versatile than others that have a definitive bottom and top.

Cost and Value

The prices for these baby comforters are fairly consistent, so the price range is small. We calculate an average of all featured items, so we can compare it to each cost in its own Cost and Value section above. Because the price change so often online, we do not list specific costs, but we do tell you how each product stands economically against the others. We do that by stating if the product is average, below-average, or above-average in cost. we also tell you the terrific features or qualities that make up the value of each one. The baby comforter with the highest price is the Just for Baby White Down Comforter, and the one that has the lowest cost is the Tadpoles Toddler Comforter with the Teddy Pattern. As you can see, a few of these are sets with several components, while others are just the comforter itself. This will account for some of the price differences when comparing items across the board.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Which comforters are suitable for both boys and girls to give as a baby shower gift?

A: The comforters that are great for both sexes are the Nojo 3-Piece Safari Kids Comforter Set, the Disney Dumbo 3-Piece Crib Bedding Set, the Tadpoles Toddler Comforter with the Teddy Pattern, the Burt’s Bees Baby Reversible Quilt, and the Just for Baby White Down Comforter. These all have gender-neutral colors that can be used for both sexes well and given as gifts for baby showers.

Q: What is the most common complaint of these comforters online by customers?

A: Pilling is a common complaint as well as the size being too small or too large. Pilling occurred after washing some of these comforters several times. The sizes are usually stated in each of the product’s description from the makers. Most of these will fit a standard-sized crib and be large enough for the toddler years also. If they are too big, they can always be folded down to accommodate the size.

Q: What is the best way to clean these comforters? Can they all be machine washed?

A: They can all be machine washed except the Pink and Grey Soft Cot Comforter that is a handmade quilt. The manufacturer states at the bottom of the product description that it must be dry cleaned. In another spot, they do say it can be machine washed. There were several comments online from customers saying that it had to be dry cleaned, so that is most probably correct.

Q: Which products come with more than just the comforter? What are the extra pieces?

A: The ones that have a title that says sets or tells how many pieces that are included. Most of them have three pieces, which include the comforter, a bed skirt, and a fitted sheet. The one that has four items also includes a regular sheet beside a fitted one. All other products just include the comforter alone.

Q: Do any of these offer a choice in colors or designs?

A: Yes, several of the designs give you a choice in color and some for the pattern. Most of them do not, especially the solid gray or white ones. The unisex colors or designs do not have options for colors either. The American Baby Company 4-Piece Toddler Bedding Set is offered in eight different colors for their basic design. You can choose colors great for girls or boys if you know the sex of the child. Several unisex hues are available if you do not know.

Q: What are most of these covers filled with?

A: Most of them have polyester or cotton stuffing inside of them, but one has goose down inside the comforter. These are all soft, thick, and warm to keep the child very comfortable in the bed or crib. They are puffy and will get softer with each time they are washed.

Q: What ages of children are these comforters for, as some of them say, infant or toddler?

A: This was an issue online with customers too. Some of them were disappointed with the sizes they received. They either expected a bigger or smaller item than what was sent. Although most of the products give the dimensions of the covers, it can be a shock when it arrives and is not what was expected. It seems as though manufacturers tried to bridge a gap between infants and toddlers by making some of these comforters in a larger than needed size for cribs. Some of them are large enough for a toddler’s bed, making them a bit big for a baby’s crib. It is always good to have more cover than you need, as they can always be folded to take up the slack. The majority of these are for babies to fit in their cribs, while a few of them are large enough for toddlers.

Sources

  1. George Cohen, What kind of bedding is best for my baby?, Online Article,
  2. Unknown Author, Introducing & using a comforter, Online Article,
  3. CPSC Blogger, Safe Sleep: Bedding, Pillows, Safety and More, Online Article,