10 Best Halloween Candy Reviewed in 2024
Stacey Joseph
Halloween night is a big night. The kids love dressing up and walking around the neighborhood to visit all their friends to show off their fun costume. The plus note is there is always a yummy treat at the door. Sometimes handing out candy can seem like a task when you are just not sure what to buy. We have created a list of the best halloween candy. This list includes all the candies that the kids love and some classics as well. You will sure to be a hit with all the visitors this year.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 40 hrs of research
Has the highest number of reviews online
Is a thirty-count box of assorted chocolate candy bars
Use for Halloween gift bags, party favors, or trick-or-treat
Can be eaten as they are or used in recipes
The box includes Reese’s, Kit Kat, Hershey’s, and Hershey’s with almonds
10 Best Halloween Candy
1. Hershey's Chocolate Bar Pack
Has the highest number of reviews online
Is a thirty-count box of assorted chocolate candy bars
Use for Halloween gift bags, party favors, or trick-or-treat
Can be eaten as they are or used in recipes
The box includes Reese’s, Kit Kat, Hershey’s, and Hershey’s with almonds
Some buyers received melted candy
A couple of people had only a few Hershey bars in their pack
This variety pack of Hershey’s chocolate has the highest number of reviews online for this category and a large satisfaction rating from satisfied customers. This item is a thirty-count box of assorted chocolate candy bars that are perfect to use for Halloween decorations, prizes, gift bags, party favors, or trick-or-treat giveaways.
Read moreDesign
The individual bars can be eaten and enjoyed just as they are, or they can be blended into delicious dessert recipes. These are perfect for sharing, and they are kosher. The assortment in the box includes ten Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, six Kit Kat Wafer Bars, seven Hershey’s Milk Chocolate with Almond Bars, and seven Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bars. Enjoy America’s favorite candy this Halloween with this terrific variety pack of favorites!
Value
This thirty-count box is great for Halloween party favors, gift bags, or door treats for the costumed guests you will receive on a special night. they will want to come back for seconds when they know you have Hershey’s.
Entertainment Value
Who does not absolutely love and cherish Hershey’s? Everything they make is so great! Hershey’s chocolate is great for so many things and times in your life from snacks to holiday treats.
Price Range
Understandably, this is the most expensive item on this candy list. It is top-quality Hershey’s candy with the most popular flavors in full-sized bars in a thirty-count box.
2. Jolly Rancher - Hard
Can be crushed and sprinkled onto holiday desserts
Is a five-pound bag with 375 pieces
Includes five well-known fruits
Is the original hard candy that everyone loves
A trusted favorite for many generations
Some customers did not receive equal amounts of the different flavors
A few had candies that were not individually wrapped in the bag
Jolly Rancher Hard Candy has been a trusted favorite of all ages for many generations. The perfect-sized colorful nuggets are ideal for decorations, gift bags, trick-or-treat, party favors, table displays, and daily snacking.
Read moreDesign
Mix them in with favorite dessert recipes or enjoy them as they are. Individual Jolly Ranchers can be crushed and sprinkled onto cakes, cupcakes, and cookies for holiday desserts. This item is a five-pound bag of assorted fruity flavors with 375 pieces in the bag. The mix includes the flavors of grape, cherry, apple, watermelon, and blue raspberry. Enjoy the original hard candy that everyone loves and loves to receive this holiday season.
Value
When you want to give out a treat for Halloween that everyone will enjoy, give them Jolly Rancher candy. People of all ages recognize the mouth-watering morsels that dissolve in your mouth so slowly.
Entertainment Value
If you love fruity candy, then Jolly Rancher is the candy for you! All of the flavors are tangy, fun, and long-lasting in the mouth because they are rock hard and delicious.
Price Range
With a cost well below the average for this category, Jolly Rancher has always been an economical choice for candy. The bold fruity assortment of flavors in this huge bag is well worth the cost.
3. Candy Party Mix Bag
Great mix of fun candy
Name brand individually wrapped candy treats
Each mini packet is labeled with the brand name
Perfect for little to big visitors
Ideal for picky treat eaters or allegories
Candy is not an even count of any one kind
Small bags of gummy treats are hard to open
An assortment of candy that allows everyone to find something that they love. This huge bag of candy is great for Halloween visitors. It includes a mix of mini packets of all the best candy. It includes gummy fish, skittles, nerds, gummy bears, and so much more.
Read moreDesign
It is a great variety of the biggest names in the candy market and all packaged perfectly for giving to all your guests. The candy comes in a large bag and inside the bag, you will find lots of mini packets of individually wrapped candy. The candy is all wrapped with the brand logos making it easy to spot the ones you love plus it makes it easy when giving candy away to be able to find candy for the guests that best matches their age range. The bag of candy gives you plenty of each kind and is a 10-ounce bag full of yummy treats. It is a wonderful variety of candy that is easy to hand out and will have everyone stopping back at your house again next year.
Value
Using an assortment of name brand candy like this package makes it easy to be able to hand out candy to the kids and friends. The packages are clearly labeled and individually wrapped. It makes it nice when you have someone with a dislike for one type of candy or any allegories.
Entertainment Value
All the best candy all mixed in one place. This mix of brand name candy is a great mix of all the treats that kids and parents love. The best part is the individual packaging. It makes it super easy to pass out to the kids. Grab a couple and smiles were all around.
Price Range
This is an averaged priced assorted bag of candy on our list. It is an average value for the brand name and amount of candy that you receive.
4. SKITTLES & STARBURST Fun Size
Large bag of two different candies; Skittles and Starburst
Pieces are individually wrapped for easy distribution
Fun size pieces perfect for trick or treaters
Starburst are fruity chewy square candies flavors; lemon, orange, cherry, and strawberry
Skittles are small round candy flavors; lemon, orange, grape, strawberry, and green apple
Often reported that Starburst is mostly strawberry flavor
Starburst packages can be tough to open
When Halloween time comes around you want to make sure that you have candy that the kits will love. Nothing worse than buying candy that everyone just takes home and tosses in the trash. This mix of Skittles and Starburst is the perfect blend of candy for your trick or treaters. Each bag includes lots of pieces to make sure there are lots to go around.
Read moreDesign
Featured in the large bag of 31.9 ounces of candy is both the Starburst candy and the Skittles candy. Both candies are sweet treats that are kid friendly and fun to eat. Each bag includes 65 pieces of individually wrapped candy making them easy to pass out. The Skittles candy is a small round sugary bite of candy that has a fruity taste. The flavors include; lemon, orange, grape, strawberry, and green apple. Starbursts are a chewy square candy that is also fruity and sweet. Included flavors from that brand are; lemon, orange, cherry, and strawberry.
Value
The fun size pre packaged candies each come individually wrapped making it convenient and easy to be able to distribute the candy when Halloween time comes. Each of the bags of candy comes with one pound and 15.9 ounces of mixed Skittles and Starburst which comes out to about 65 pieces of candy. The value for the quality and quantity is something that will have you purchasing this bag each year around this time and maybe even sometimes just because.
Entertainment Value
Nothing is funner than opening a little bag of Skittles and seeing what flavors that you got. Each kid has their favorite candy flavor of each brand and Skittles is one brand that the kids love seeing what ‘colors’ they get. Then when it comes time to open the Starburst trying new ones or just sticking to the ones they know they love is nice. It is a delicious fruit chew that will bring a smile to their faces.
Price Range
Purchasing this large bag of 65 pieces of candy is a win, win for everyone. It features two different brands and textures of candy at an average price point for the number of pieces that you receive in each bag. It gives you a great opportunity to stock up on a couple of brands of candy that everyone loves.
5. Brach's Candy Corn, 70 count packs
Classic candy corn themed treats
Each bag includes 70 treat packs
Features Halloween colored and themed treat
Perfect treat for parties or baking
Easy to share making every moment even sweeter
Each treat bag does not include the same amount of candy
Texture of the candy can be harder for some
When it comes to celebrating Halloween we all have the first thought of candy. Oh, the yummy, sugary, and delicious candy. Most of the people love Halloween candy because is also includes candy corn. Candy corn is a corn kernel shaped candy that is sweet and makes a great seasonal treat. The candy is even color coordinator for the holiday seaso
Read moreDesign
These candy corn treats are by the brand, Brachs. This is a well-known candy company that has created this special treat for this time of year. The design of the treat is a corn kernel shaped to make it fun to eat and match with all the other décor of the season. Along with the candy treat itself being designed for Halloween this bag of treats is made just for passing out to friends. The treats are made into treat packs. Each bag includes 70 packs of individually wrapped packs.
Value
Nothing makes Halloween sweeter than this candy corn treat packs. The company has designed and made everything from jelly beans to gummy bears to make every occasion special. They have also done it with these treats as well. They are well designed, with a great amount in each pack, and with the Halloween themed colored they are a perfect candy for your party treat.
Entertainment Value
Adding to treat bags or just tossing right into their Halloween sacks kids will have a smile on their face when they see these candy corn packs coming their way. They are able to sweeten the holiday season with each little corn kernel. It is the perfect seasonal candy that makes the moment special.
Price Range
The price point on this bag of Halloween candy is great. It includes 70 treat packs of candy corn for a low price. That allows you to be able to treat tons of kids for a very fair price while still giving them each something that they will love. Each year when they receive these little treat bags it will remind them of the special moments associated with the Halloween season from the years before.
6. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Miniatures
The lovable combination of peanut butter and chocolate
All are individually wrapped in pretty gold foils
Gluten-free and kosher candy
A favorite of America for over 75 years
It is the number one Halloween trick-or-treat candy
A few people had melted candy
Some complaints of stale chocolate
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Miniature is the number one Halloween trick-or-treat giveaway candy in the country. It has also been a favorite in America as a regular staple candy for over 75 years.
Read moreDesign
It is the mouth-watering combination of creamy-style peanut butter and delicious milk chocolate that everyone knows and loves in the miniature-sized cups. They are all individually wrapped in pretty gold foils and are gluten-free and kosher. This fabulous product is a forty-ounce bulk pack of candy that has about 130 pieces of candy inside. Share them with friends and family or blend into a huge variety of holiday dessert recipes for your welcomed guests.
Value
This terrific candy has pleased Americans for over 75 years with its traditional flavor of simple creamy peanut butter and milk chocolate. It is loved by young and old and everyone in-between.
Entertainment Value
Anyone who likes chocolate and peanut butter mixed together loves the taste of Reese’s. It is a flavor known around the world but especially appreciated for Halloween.
Price Range
On the lower end of the cost, scale is this forty-ounce bag of Reese’s because it is a small pack compared to some of the other items listed. This trusted favorite is always a crowd-pleaser because of the high-quality and the brand name>.
7. Swedish Fish Soft and Chewy
A red chewy candy that is delicious and soft
They are a fat-free treat
Perfect for both adults and kids
Has a delightful fruity taste
Is a bulk package with 240 candies
Flavor was off for some people that love this candy
A few did not care for the texture
Much like Gummy Bears in texture and flavor, these wonderful Swedish Fish candies are red chewy treats that are delicious, soft, and gummy.
Read moreDesign
Even though they are shaped like a fish, these fantastic candies have a light fruity taste that is desired by both kids and adults alike. This is a bulk package with 240 individually wrapped candies inside. You can feel great about eating these because they are a fat-free treat, so just dig in and enjoy!
Value
This is a bulk pack of 240 individually wrapped candies, that is perfect and plentiful enough to use for party favors, treat bags, candy dishes, and decorative edible arrangements.
Entertainment Value
When you don’t want something chocolate for Halloween, then grab some of these Swedish Fish candies. They have a great texture and fruity flavor that almost anyone will love.
Price Range
Having an average price, these Swedish Fish candies are perfect for Halloween parties and giveaways because they are individually wrapped. This is a bulk package that is well worth the cost.
8. Airheads Bars Chewy Fruit Variety Pack
Can purchase as a mixture or one single favorite flavor
Is a wonderful treat size and great for sharing
Ideal for giveaways, party favors, and treat bags
Are gluten-free, kosher, and allergy-free
Does not contain any of the “Big 8” allergy trigger foods
Some mixtures received were not equally distributed among the flavors
A few people received mashed candy
This fabulous variety package of Airheads Bars is a bulk package of ninety individually wrapped non-melting candies. You can purchase as a mixture of flavors or as a whole box of one single favorite flavor of your choice. It is a wonderful treat size and great for sharing.
Read moreDesign
This assortment is ideal for giveaways, party favors, decorations, edible arrangements, and treat bags. These superb candies are gluten-free, kosher, and allergy-free, plus they do not contain any of the “Big 8” allergy trigger foods of shellfish, wheat, fish, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, milk, or eggs. Individual pieces can be molded or cut into unique designs for decorating desserts and party food trays. Get some today for your holiday guests!
Value
For those that suffer from food allergies, Airheads is one of the best candies they can enjoy and be safe. This amazing candy lacks the “Big 8” trigger foods that can make allergy sufferers quite ill.
Entertainment Value
Kids love fruity flavors and they simply adore taffy textured candy. These two ideas come together in the form of Airheads Bars. They have great appeal for the young to the old.
Price Range
These Airhead Bars cost just under the average for the Halloween candy on this list. They are valued for their assorted fruity flavors, fun size, and variety of unique uses for holidays.
9. Tootsie Roll Midgees Value Bag
Can be purchased as one bag, a tub, or a pack of three bags
Comes as a five-pound bag containing 760 pieces
The same chocolatey favorite you remember
Is the great classic flavor everyone loves
Can be enjoyed by babies and toddlers
Some said the taste was different than they remembered
A couple of people had sticky wrappers
Small enough to be enjoyed by babies and toddlers, these Tootsie Roll Midgees come in a five-pound value bag for the little witches and ghosts who will be coming to your door for Halloween. There are 760 Tootsie Rolls in this huge bag, and it can be purchased as one bag, a tub, or a pack of three bags online.
Read moreDesign
This is the chocolatey favorite you remember from your childhood because it is the classic flavor that everyone loves. This bag is reclosable, and the pieces are small enough to be enjoyed by babies and toddlers. Online customers love the fresh candy they received that is so much better than what regular stores are offering. Treat your Halloween guests well with some Tootsie Rolls for their surprise this year.
Value
This five-pound bag should last a while for Halloween giveaways depending on how many little ghosts and goblins come your way. They will all be delighted to see the goodies you have for them.
Entertainment Value
Tootsie Rolls never go out of style no matter what size they are. These are the midges that everyone loves to eat, even if you have to eat twenty of thirty to get your fill of them.
Price Range
With an above average cost, these Tootsie Roll Midgees have the fantastic quality that you have trusted and liked for years, plus this is a super-sized bag of 760 candy pieces.
10. Smarties Rolls
Is a colorful roll of fruity wafers
Will not become a mess in hot weather
Is the perfect sweet treat anytime
Safe for those with Celiac Disease
Is gluten-free and vegan
Flavor was off for a few buyers
Some complaints of candy not being very fresh
Smarties have the highest rating online from customers as one of the top candies for Halloween. This is a five-pound bag of Smarties Candy Rolls that is a great size to purchase for those trick-or-treaters that come knocking on Halloween night.
Read moreDesign
Each individually wrapped candy is a colorful roll of fruity wafers that will not melt. They will not become a mess in hot weather and are the perfect sweet treat anytime. Smarties candy has been a leading treat for Halloween for more than fifty years because it is such a versatile treat. It is safe for those with Celiac Disease and is gluten-free and vegan. With this online offer, you can purchase as one, three, or four five-pound packs for all of your Halloween visitors.
Value
Smarties have been around for over fifty years, so it is quite clear that people of several generations are crazy for them. They delight everyone that tries them, as it is hard to not like them.
Entertainment Value
There are not many other candies anywhere that are colorful and joyful as Smarties. They are perfect for all ages because of their rainbow of fruity flavors and adorable size.
Price Range
This five-pound bag of Smarties has an average Halloween candy price and is worth the value with its colorful goodness, longstanding reputation, and healthier-than-most ingredients.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Design
Halloween candy, especially for the door-to-door surprises, must be wrapped individually for cleanliness and sanitation purposes. It also serves as a labeling mechanism too, so kids and parents know exactly what the child is receiving from neighbors. Small pieces of candy are ideal because neighbors must give out a lot of candy during that one special night. It is more economical to give out small treats to everyone, to make sure all kids get a treat.
This is the reason to buy in bulk packages like the ones on this list. Make sure that candy that is for others has the wrappers intact and they are not sticky or melted. Any wrappers that are torn or mangled should be thrown out and not given to kids.
Value
The most reviewed candy for Halloween online this year is the Hershey’s Chocolate Candy Bar Variety Pack with almost 1.500 reviews. The candy with the best rating is the Smarties Candy Rolls because of its versatility and rainbow of colors in each pack. All of these items have the best reviews from consumers online and the most reviews of all offerings of Halloween candy. We spotlight them here for your enhanced shopping of the perfect treat choice this year.
Even though almost everyone is familiar with these candy brands and what they taste like, we give you the details of the included flavors, package size, piece amount, and treat ideas for each one in the informative summary sections. In this way, you can make the best decision as to which candy you would like to offer this year to the little ghosts and goblins that come to your door for treats.
Entertainment Value
Not only are these candies perfect for giving out on Halloween night for trick-or-treating, but they also have many other purposes for this holiday. For parties, the options are almost endless, but we will name a few. They can be put in party treat bags, used as colorful table decorations, and added into floral arrangements. They also make wonderful additions to edible decorative assortments, candy dishes, and party favors as fillers. When they are unwrapped, they can be added to holiday dessert recipes or made into cupcakes, cookies, tarts, and lollipops. There are recipes that the manufacturers have on the bags of candy, or you can go online to find the perfect holiday recipe to delight your guests this year.
Price Range
The package sizes, individual candy size, and the type of candy account for the variation in the costs of these candies. Hershey’s chocolate is at both ends of the list with the highest and lowest priced items. We do elaborate on the value and size of each product in its very own Cost and Value section.
Entertainment Value Design Value Price Range 
Before kids go trick or treating, parents should make sure to provide a healthy meal for their children so they do not overeat candy. Before they feel sick, children should mind their candy and sweets intake. Anything that is not entirely wrapped should not be accepted.
Halloween teaches children to socialize with others and be more open to social situations. Shy children are able to interact with their friends and neighbors.
Other Factors to Consider
Taste
Japan now sells almost 300 flavors of the popular Kit Kat bar, such as butter, chili, purple sweet potato, coconut, strawberry, wasabi, and cheesecake. They began selling them there in 2000.
Brand
Customers spend about $2.1 billion for Halloween candy each year, or an average of $47 for each US citizen.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups is the most popular candy in the nation for Halloween.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: Are all of these candies individually wrapped?
Yes, each type on this list is a bag or box of individually wrapped small candies perfect for giving out for Halloween. These can be used for party favors, candy dishes, treat bags, table decorations, edible arrangements, or trick-or-treat giveaways. They are all small bite-size pieces of the favorites we crave and love.
q: How do you know how many pieces of candy are in each package?
Most of the manufacturer descriptions of the most popular halloween candy types did list the number of pieces in each package. When this was given, we noted it in each item’s summary for you. If it was not given, then you will have to guess as to how many are in the bag according to the weight and approximate size of each piece.
q: What is the biggest complaint about ordering bulk candy online?
The thing most customers complained about for this candy ordered online was the fact that it can and does melt in transport. This is true, especially of the chocolate candy, such as Hershey’s or Reese’s. Even though the sellers do pack the candy often with cold packs to keep the candy cool in transit, that even gets hot, depending on where the shipment has to travel. Mailboxes and mail trucks can get awfully warm and sometimes quite hot, so keep this in mind when ordering. In warmer climates, it would be best not to order a product that you know would melt. Try for something more stable such as the Smarties Candy Rolls, Swedish Fish, or Airheads Bars that could stand up better to hot conditions that the ever-popular chocolate favorites.
q: What is the customer favorite among all of these choices for Halloween?
The candy item with the highest customer rating is the Smarties Candy Rolls. These are quite popular and have been for years as one of the most perfect Halloween candies to give out. Close seconds in customer satisfaction are the Airheads Bars, Jolly Rancher Hard Candy, and the Tootsie Roll Midgees. These are all wonderful treats to put in kids bags this year.
q: When is a kid too old to go trick-or-treating?
We would have to say never to this question because Halloween is fun for everyone. There is no set rule for when kids stop trick-or-treating because of age, but in general, they stop wanting to go around the teen years because they may feel it is too childish. As long as there are younger relatives in the family to bring around for treats, teens may still want to go as a supervisor for the little children. In this way, they can still go and have fun around the neighborhood.
q: Should pets go out for Halloween when the family goes trick-or-treating?
Sure, pets, especially dogs love to go out with the kids and family on Halloween night for trick-or-treating. It is not advisable to give them any of the candy treats, but they like to get dressed up in costume and go door-to-door too. We even have a special Halloween buying guide for dog Halloween costumes that you may want to check out for the furry member of the family.
Sources
- , Why do we give out candy on Halloween? Blame the Irish., Online Article
- , 14 Mind-Blowing Things You Didn’t Know About Halloween Candy, Online Article
- , Why Do We Give Out Candy On Halloween? Here's How The Tradition Began, Online Article
