The Best Newborn Baby Pacifiers & Soothers Reviewed in 2019

The first pacifier in medical literature appeared in the year 1473. That means soothers, binkies, dummies, or whatever else you’d like to call them have been on the scene for several centuries now. Pacifiers, while not recommended during the first month of breastfeeding, have been linked to a decrease in SIDS, and are a preferred alternative to children sucking on their fingers and thumbs in some households. Pacifiers are typically characterized by a soft nipple-like protrusion, a mouth guard that keeps baby from swallowing or choking on it, and a handle for ease of removal and travel. Soothers are soft (generally silicone, rubber, or plastic) and often calm babies. Below, we’ve gathered ten of the most popular options available on the current market. Enjoy!

Last Updated:
By Angeline Mirenda:

Our most recent update to this page brings you one new product with exceptional ratings across the board from all the parents and babies that have tested it already. We’ve also slimmed down our product list to ensure that each and every item on this guide is an accurate fit for your needs while still maintaining the highest quality.

Criteria Used in Evaluation of the Best Baby Pacifiers & Soothers

Selecting the best pacifiers and soothers for parents can be a tough choice. That is where we come in to help. We have created this list with the best new baby pacifiers and soothers. The question you may ask yourself is: how do they determine what the best is?

We have a panel of research experts that review the market for information on pacifiers. They then work to determine what pacifiers offer the best designs and are most often accepted by newborns. The designs of the pacifiers vary from the way the nipple has been designed, what they have been constructed from, and even cute features or accessories. The best designs seem to be the simplest with the most contour to the mouth.

Once we were able to determine the best designs we then worked on the test to determine what the most accepted pacifiers by newborns are. This search was completed by looking at consumer reviews and information from parents on what pacifiers their newborns and babies were using. The list was composed with parents and newborns in mind. We want to suggest nothing but the best pacifiers for your babies. We hope this list helps you find the best for your baby.

Benefits of using Pacifiers & Soothers

When babies are born they are made to suck. They have the instinct to suck for nutrition, but often it goes beyond that and parents find that many babies will also suck to sooth. When babies are viewed in the womb they can be observed sucking their thumbs or fingers. Research has determined that the instinct is to help soothe and calm them. Pacifiers are often used once they are born and offer many advantages. Some advantages to consider are:

  • Soothe a fussy baby: some babies are very happy when they are sucking on a pacifier offer temporary distractions when they are upset: pacifiers come in handy after shots or when they are upset
  • Help them fall asleep: when babies have a hard time settling down, pacifiers can help
  • Might help reduce SIDS: researchers say that sucking during bedtime or naptime may
  • help reduce the risk for SIDS
Giving breastfed babies pacifiers

Experts recommend that pacifiers are not introduced to breastfeeding newborns for the first three to four weeks after they are born. They have found that artificial nipples can cause nipple confusion and can make the experience hard for both the baby and mommy. It is suggested that once mom’s milk supply is well established and a breastfeeding routine has been created that a pacifier can come in handy for parents.
It is best to keep in mind that you should only use the pacifier as little as possible. It is always up to the parents how and what comforts you want to give your baby, but keep in mind that there is no evidence that babies need anything to suck on outside the need to eat. It is only a personal choice to present them with something to help calm them at times.

Pacifiers and Reducing the Risk for SIDS

There are many considerations to think about when you’re first making the choice to put a pacifier in your baby’s mouth. Once you have made that decision it is also nice to know that a pacifier could save your baby’s life.

Researchers have been able to link a decreased risk in babies that use pacifiers with the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Many experts have been researching this for many years and it appears from their study that babies that suck may not go into a deep sleep. This makes it easier for them to wake up and makes them less vulnerable to SIDS. The link between the two now has the American Academy of Pediatrics suggesting that pacifiers be used for babies under the age of one, but at least one month old or until feeding schedules have been well established.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Q How do you sterilize and clean pacifiers?

A: Before using a pacifier and at regular intermissions, you should boil the pacifier in water for up to five minutes. When doing this avoids leaving the pacifier in the water more than the five minutes. This could cause water to enter the inside of the nipple. If water enters the nipple it can cause the nipple to flatten and cause ventilation issues.

Q: How often should I replace my baby’s pacifier?

A: For hygiene reasons a pacifier should be replaced at least every two months. When they start to teeth you should always replace the pacifier at the first sight of ANY damage or weakness.

Q: What is the difference between pacifier nipples made from silicone or latex?

A: Latex is a softer more natural rubber. It is created from more eco-friendly materials and it much more flexible than silicone nipples. The major downfall of latex is after lots of use the material can break down and change. Plus when it is stored in a hot area for a period of time it can lose it shape. Silicone nipples are a type of plastic that does not change, but it isn’t bite resistant and is even less resilient than latex.

Q: How long should I let my baby use a pacifier for?

A: It is recommended that pacifiers should not be used after their first birthday, but there is no evidence to suggest that there will be any damage if the use of a pacifier continues to 3 years of age. After 36 months damaging effects can result from the use of a pacifier.

Q: Where can I buy the 10 products listed?

A: All of these products are available on Amazon. If you simply click on either the picture or the link below, you’ll be taken to the product’s page. This page includes the ability to switch sizes and colors (if that’s available), as well as all of the customer reviews and ratings at the bottom, in case you’re interested in doing further research. Some of these pacifiers may additionally be available in stores or through other websites, but given Amazon’s protective customer practices, prompt delivery, and the ability to schedule re-orders, we think Amazon is your most convenient option.

Q: Is it okay that my 3-month-old baby will only sleep when there is a pacifier in their mouth?

A: Yes, it is okay that they will only sleep with the pacifier in. Lots of babies at this age have the need to suck and it helps soothe them as they sleep. They only disadvantage is many babies cannot place the pacifier back in their mouth so if it falls out it causes you to have to come to the rescue each time.

Sources

  1. Mayo Clinic Staff, Pacifers? Are They Good for Your Baby?, Online Article, Jul 22, 2017
  2. Rachel Reiff Ellis, Pacifers: In or Out?, WebMD Informative Article, May 27, 2015
  3. American Baby, 5 Binky Basics: What you Need to Know about Pacifers, Parents.com Online Article, Feb 01, 2014
  4. Today Moms, No more nipple confusion: Study says pacifiers may help breast-feeding, Informative Article, Oct 14, 2016
  5. Yelena Moroz Alpert, The Pros and Cons of Pacifier Use, Online Article, Nov 01, 2017