Best Crib Sheets Reviewed and Rated in 2018

New parents to be love to decorate their new addition’s bedroom, more commonly known as the baby nursery. The nursery is where you and your newborn will spend most of your time together. This is where diaper changes happen, daily outfits are picked out and where your little peanut will take naps or even sleep at night. The most important part of any nursery is the crib. The most important part of any crib is the crib sheet. Here you will find our picks for the top ten best crib sheets.

These crib sheets will make a great addition to any nursery. Our list has crib sheets that will work for boys, girls, and gender neutral sheets. You will find something that will work beautifully with your nursery decor and keep your little love bug comfy and cozy during nap time and nighttime. These crib sheets will keep your baby cool in the summer and warm in the winter. They are a great addition to your nursery decor. Don’t let your baby’s crib sheet become an afterthought. Get a good set of crib sheets today!

The sheets on our list will not irritate your baby’s tender new skin. They will provide a soft respite so your baby can sleep comfortably. All of these sheets will withstand multiple trips through the washer and dryer. They all have elastic edging to keep them secure on your selected crib mattress. There are sheets of all types on our list. You can find organic sheets, conventional sheets, and sheets with a variety of fabrics. You are sure to find your perfect crib sheet here. You can rest easy knowing your new addition has a comfortable and safe bed for sleeping when you have selected the right crib sheet.

10 Best Crib Sheets Reviewed 

 

1. Brolex Stretchy Fitted

1. Brolex Stretchy Fitted
The Brolex Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheet is number one on our list. This sheet is made of soft material so your baby will be comfortable. It will not slip off of your baby’s crib mattress.
Expand to see more
This sheet set will have your nursery looking fashionable and your baby feeling comfortable. The fabric this sheet is made of can help to keep your baby cool on a warm summer night. The soft cozy Brolex sheets in this set will have your baby snuggling down to sleep in no time.

Benefits
These sheets are super soft and will keep your baby feeling cozy. The jersey knit fabric will keep your baby cool during the night. The elastic edging makes it easy quickly change this sheet as needed when your little cutie makes a mess. You and your little one will be glad to have these crib sheets around.

What We Like About It
This crib sheet will help keep your baby at a comfortable temperature while they sleep. It is soft and cozy and will stay in place as your little one wiggles around the crib. The fully elastic edging is a great safety feature to keep this sheet fitting snugly all night long.

Cost and Value
This crib sheet is priced at the bottom of our list. It is a fantastic value for a great jersey knit sheet. You will be pleased with the money you spend on this crib sheet.
Pros

Jersey knit material

Full elastic edging

Machine washable

Soft

Cute patterns

Cons

The material can pill over time

2. Burt's Bees Thin Stripes

2. Burt's Bees Thin Stripes
Burt’s Bees Crib Sheet nabs our number two spot. This crib sheet is 100% organic so you don’t have to worry about synthetic materials near your baby’s precious skin.
Expand to see more
This sheet is packed with safety features so both you and your little peanut can rest easy. The gender-neutral design will work with any nursery decor. This is the perfect sheet for your baby’s sleeping needs.

Benefits
Burt’s Bees fitted crib sheets contain BeeSnug 360 degree premium elastic. This premium elastic is around the entire edge of the sheet and it is fully encased. This sheet also has an extra long overlap at the bottom to keep the sheet in place. These amazing safety features will help to keep the sheet from moving around and keep your little one sleeping safely.

What We Like About It
The best feature of this sheet is the GOTS certified 100% organic cotton fabric it is made from. You don’t have to worry about harsh chemicals in this sheet, because Burt’s Bees only uses organic cotton that was grown without the use of pesticides. This material is anti-pill and super breathable, so your baby will be comfortable for many nights to come.

Cost and Value
The price for this premium crib sheet is near the top of our list. You will love the fact that you are laying your baby down on an organic sheet that is loaded with safety features. Your little love bug will love the fact that it is made from super soft and breathable material.
Pros

100% organic cotton

BeeSnug fully encased elastic edging

Anti-pill fabric

Gender neutral design

Easy to care for

Cons

The extra material near the bottom can cause the fabric to sag on some mattresses

The 360 elastic can make it difficult to put on the crib mattress

3. Amazon Basics Heather Jersey

3. Amazon Basics Heather Jersey
This Amazon Basics brand crib sheet has our number three spot. This super soft crib sheet is like sleeping on your favorite old t-shirt.
Expand to see more
The material is very breathable to keep your little peanut at peak comfort throughout the night. It will stay put snuggly on your crib mattress. This is one crib sheet you will love to use again and again.

Benefits
This sheet comes in a variety of colors to fit your carefully thought out nursery decor. The one hundred percent cotton fibers work to wick away moisture. If your baby sweats during the night, this sheet will keep your little one comfortable and dry. You will be glad you have this crib sheet on hot summer nights.

What We Like About It
The jersey knit material is super soft and comfortable. Your little one will love to rest their face against this sheet. The softness will help to lull them into a deep sleep. When it inevitably gets dirty just pop it in the washer and dryer for a quick and easy clean.

Cost and Value
This crib sheet is near the bottom of our price list. It is a fantastic buy for a cozy comfy sheet that will help your baby sleep well. This sheet is super affordable, you should go and buy a few!
Pros

Easy to clean

Soft

Durable

Fashionable

Safe

Cons

Very stretchy

4. M & Y Fitted 3-PACK

4. M & Y Fitted 3-PACK
The M&Y Fitted Crib Sheet is our number four pick. This sheet is soft and safe for your little love bug. You will feel confident that your baby is safe with this sheet in their crib.
Expand to see more
The material is breathable so it is good for any climate. This soft and durable sheet will keep your baby comfortable for a cozy night of sleep. It is perfect for nap time too! This crib sheet will have you feeling safe and baby sleeping soundly.

Benefits
This sheet has a nine-inch skirt. A sheet skirt is the section of the sheet that goes around the sides of the mattress. The reason a nine-inch sheet skirt is a benefit is that it will have more material to tuck around the bottom of the mattress and be less likely to come off during regular use.

What We Like About It
This sheet set comes in a package of three so you already have half of the sheets you will need all in one package. This is the perfect set of sheets to purchase for a baby shower gift. These sheets will stay put and keep your baby comfortable while they sleep. These are the best sheets for your little peanut.

Cost and Value
The price of these sheets is near to the bottom of our price list. These sheets are a great value! your pocketbook will be pleased and your baby will be snuggly in the soft comfort of these sheets.
Pros

Hypoallergenic

Soft material

Easy to clean

Breathable fabric

100% money back guarantee

Cons

Not as stretchy as other sheets

Double check the size of your mattress, this sheet will sometimes fit to loose or too snug

5. American Baby Company

5. American Baby Company
The American Baby Company has our number five spot. This sheet is super soft like your favorite t-shirt. It will surround your crib mattress in cozy comfort and make sleepy time comfy for your little baby.
Expand to see more
These sheets are perfect to grow with your little one. They can fit on your crib mattress and your toddler mattress.

Benefits
American Baby Company made these sheets out of three different pieces of soft jersey material. The longer sides of the sheets ate separate pieces of material to help the sheet stay in place on your baby’s crib mattress. This is a great safety feature that will make you feel comfortable leaving your new baby to sleep for naps and bedtime.

What We Like About It
This soft sheet only has elastic on the short sides so it will be easier to put on your baby’s bed. You don’t have to fight with pulling it down on all sides. It also has extra large nine-inch pockets so it won’t slip off the baby’s mattress.

Cost and Value
The price of this sheet is the lowest on our list. It is a fantastic value. You will feel comfortable leaving your baby to sleep on this cozy sheet.
Pros

Stylish

3 piece construction

9-inch side pockets

Soft

Easy to clean

Cons

Elastic is only on the short sides

6. Ely's & Co. 2 Pack 100% Jersey Cotton

6. Ely's & Co. 2 Pack 100% Jersey Cotton
Ely’s & Co. takes our number six spot. This sheet set comes in a group of two and it is gender neutral. It is the perfect pick for a family that does not want to know the baby’s gender until birth or a family that is having multiples.
Expand to see more
This is also great for a family that is choosing gender neutral decor for the nursery. This cozy sheet set will keep your baby comfortable and cozy. You will have a fashionable nursery with this sheet choice.

Benefits
This jersey knit cotton sheet is as cozy as an old t-shirt. Your baby will relax into its soft coziness. It comes in a set of two sheets. This sheet set is great to have on hand so you have a spare ready for any messes. You and your baby will love this sheet set!

What We Like About It
This sheet is made with adaptable elastic so it will properly fit different size crib mattresses. The Ely’s & Co. sheet set is the perfect addition to your nursery. It will allow you to quickly change the crib linens in case of messes.

Cost and Value
The price of this sheet is in the middle range for out list. You will be pleased with the price and the features this sheet set offers.
Pros

Set of 2 sheets

T-shirt like softness

Gender neutral pattern

Adaptable elastic

High quality

Cons

Shrinks if washed in hot water

7. TILLYOU Microfiber Silky Soft

7. TILLYOU Microfiber Silky Soft
The Till You Microfiber Crib Sheet is our number seven pick. This sheet has superior softness, because of the soft microfiber material it is made from. It is environmentally friendly.
Expand to see more
It comes packed with safety features! You will love having this comfortable sheet around for your little one. They will love the silky softness and you will love the fact that it is hypoallergenic.

Benefits
This sheet is made of microfiber material that makes it feel extra silky against your baby’s soft new skin. This hypoallergenic sheet will not irritate your baby’s skin because it is allergen free. This company follows the Consumer Product Safety Standards when creating and manufacturing products. You can rest easy knowing this crib sheet is safe for your little one.

What We Like About It
This sheet has three-piece construction so you won't have to struggle to figure out how the sheet fits. It has a fully encased elastic band that is on the bottom edge of the sheet to keep it snugly secure while your baby sleeps and plays in their crib.

Cost and Value
The price point for this sheet is on the lower side for the sheets on our list. You will feel comfortable with this sheet because it is hypoallergenic and follows national safety standards. This sheet is a great value and will be easy on your pocketbook.
Pros

Microfiber material

Fully encased elastic band

3 piece construction

Follows federal CPSA standards for safety

Comes in a variety of colors

Cons

Thin material

8. Jomolly Pack Unisex Clouds

8. Jomolly  Pack Unisex Clouds
The Jomolly Crib Sheet is our number eight pick. These sheets are perfect for the little guy or girl in your life. They will fit wonderfully with any nursery decor.
Expand to see more
You will be able to lay your baby down in comfort when you choose these Jomolly crib sheets. They are easy to care for and lightweight to keep your baby in maximum comfort for the entire night or nap time. You will know your baby is resting peacefully on these sheets. You will love these crib sheets!

Benefits
These sheets are made of 100% jersey cotton and will remain comfortable wash after wash. They can be thrown right into your regular washing machine and dryer for an easy and quick clean. The soft material is perfect against your baby’s sensitive skin. These sheets are a perfect fit for your little one’s nursery.

What We Like About It
These sheets have an elastic band around the bottom edge to create a secure fit on all mattresses. You can safely lay your baby to sleep and know the crib sheet will stay secure as they roll around. This is a great sheet set for your new addition.

Cost and Value
This sheet set falls into the middle part of our price list. It is a great value because you get two sheets in one package. You can use them in a boy’s or girl’s room and they are super snuggly soft. You and your baby will be comfortable with this purchase.
Pros

Easy to clean

Gender neutral

Fully elastic bottom for a secure fit

Soft cozy fabric

Come in a set of two

Cons

The coloring of the sheets looks more green than grey

9. TL Care Heavenly Soft Chenille

9. TL Care Heavenly Soft Chenille
TL Care Crib and Toddler Sheets are our number nine pick. These soft sheets are great to keep your little one comfortable. The soft cotton construction will not irritate their gentle skin.
Expand to see more
You can rest easy knowing that these sheets have safety features to keep your little one safe all night long. These sheets are the perfect pick for your nursery. They will work for both boys and girls nurseries because this sheet comes in six different colors to match your existing decor.

Benefits
These 100% cotton sheets are jersey knit for superior softness. Your crib will be cool and cozy with these sheets on the mattress. Your baby will stay comfortable through the night. When the baby is comfortable their parents can relax and sleep too. These sheets will help your whole family feel more comfortable.

What We Like About It
The best thing about the TL Care Crib Sheet is that it has a three-panel construction. This type of sheet construction helps it to fit your mattress more snugly. These sheets should not slip around as your baby starts to move about their crib. They should stay snugly in place and provide hours of soft coziness as your little guy or gal sleeps.

Cost and Value
The price point for these sheets is at the middle range for our list. You will like the cost and baby will love the comfort. This crib sheet is the perfect pick for your nursery.
Pros

Jersey knit for softness

Easy to clean

Three panel construction

Fully elasticized bottom

Great colors

Cons

Stain easily

10. Touched by Nature

10. Touched by Nature
Touched by NAture created our number 10 crib sheet. They are a company that is committed to creating goods for baby made of 100% organic cotton. These sheets are no exception to the rule.
Expand to see more
This crib sheet comes with safety features so you can feel comfortable leaving your baby alone to sleep peacefully. The soft material will have your baby wanting to lay down in the cozy comfort of their crib. You will be able to rest easy when your little one is snug in bed with these crib sheets.

Benefits
The jersey knit material feels like your favorite old t-shirt. You love that t-shirt because of its softness, and the baby will lose their crib sheet for the same reason. This sheet is chemical free so you can feel good about allowing your baby to sleep soundly when this is their crib sheet.

What We Like About It
This specific sheet comes in a variety of colors and designs to fit any nursery decor. These sheets should last longer than nonorganic cotton sheets because they are free from harsh chemicals that can deteriorate fabric fibers over time. This is a fantastic sheet to have in your nursery.

Cost and Value
This sheet in on the higher end of our price list. If you want o to have organic cotton near your baby, you must pay a bit more. These sheets will provide your little love bug with many comfortable nights and naps.
Pros

Soft material

Well made design

Organic fabric

Bottom edge is fully elastic

Easy to clean

Cons

The super stretchy fabric may be difficult to put on the mattress

Criteria Used in Evaluation of the Best Crib Sheets

Soft

Our first and most important criteria are that the crib sheets we selected be soft against your baby’s sensitive skin. No parent wants to take their well-rested baby out of the crib to find irritated skin from a rough sheet. Comfort is key with little babies, they are new to the world and came from a place of maximum comfort. In order for your little one to get the best sleep possible they must have the highest comfort and safety levels possible. The softness of your crib sheets can easily positively affect your baby’s sleep. Use a soft crib sheet and both you and your baby will be pleased with the comfort provided.

Easy to Use

We made sure to stay away from complicated or gimmicky crib sheets. You want something easy to use. Boone wants to fiddle with a finicky sheet when their baby has a leaky diaper at night. All of the sheets on our list are easy to put on and easy to remove. The sheets go on a crib mattress the same way they go on a traditional mattress. Just pull the elastic corners around the mattress corners and you are ready to help baby settle down for some quality rest time.

Stays in Place

One big issue with fitted sheets is that they have a tendency to slip out of place with extended use. After a few days of getting into and out of bed a corner might shift off. This is not the case with the crib sheets on our list. They are all sized to perfectly fit a standard sized crib mattress. Each sheet on our list has elastic edging and corner stitching to help it stay in place even with the most wiggly little ones.

Easy to Clean

When you have a small human that poops, pees and pukes everywhere their bedding needs to be easy to clean. Each one of the crib sheets we have chosen can be washed in your washing machine for optimal cleanliness. You won’t have to worry when your little one makes the inevitable mess in their bed.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can’t baby just sleep on the crib mattress?

A: No, your baby should not sleep on a bare crib mattress. Crib mattresses are made of a waterproof plastic-type material that can be harmful to a baby’s sensitive skin. If you lay your baby directly on the crib mattress they could stick to the plastic material and damage their new skin. When you sleep your skin sheds, those dead skin cells remain in your bed when you wake up. This is why we use sheets instead of sleeping directly on a mattress. You need to be able to easily remove the dead skin cells so your baby can sleep in a clean environment. The proper crib sheet will keep your baby comfortably sleeping in a clean environment.   

Q: How many crib sheets do I need?

A: You will want to have between four and six crib sheets for your baby. You need this many crib sheets because you will have to have extras around when you are washing dirty sheets. Having this many sheets will make night time accidents less worrisome. There will be days when your baby goes through three or four sheets in one day for various reasons. This is why you need to have quite a few crib sheets on hand.  

Q: What fabric should I choose?

A: Jersey, cotton, and flannel are all types of sheets you can use for your baby. The type of sheet you choose depends mostly on your personal preferences at first. What do you think is more comfortable for your baby? As you get to know your baby you will get a better idea of what makes them comfortable. If your baby sleeps hot you will want to stick with a cooling jersey type material for crib sheets. Flannel sheets are good for babies that tend to get cool when sleeping. Cotton sheets are great to have on hand because they are soft and help keep the bed at the same temperature as the room. If you know that your baby’s room is hot or cold, then you will want to get the correct sheets to keep baby cool or warm enough. Remember jersey to cool and flannel to warm. If your baby has a room that is temperate and generally comfortable then go with a cotton sheet. The most important thing to remember is that you know your baby best and you can select the sheet that will make them the most comfortable.

Q: Why do crib sheets have elastic?

A: Crib sheets need to be able to stay securely on the crib mattress. This is for the safety of your baby. The elastic on the edges of the crib sheet holds the sheet in place as your baby sleeps and moves around their crib. If the sheet comes to lose it can get tangled around your little one. Sheets without elastic will come loose and endanger your baby. Always choose a properly sized crib sheet with elastic around the edge to keep your baby safe.  

Q: How do I clean a crib sheet?

A: You will clean a crib sheet the same way that you clean a regular bed sheet. If you are using specific gentle baby detergent, then wash your crib sheets with that detergent. Otherwise, crib sheets can be washed in the washing machine and dried in the dryer. Check your sheet’s care tag for specific water temperature and dryer heat setting.

Q: Where is the top sheet?

A: You should not use a top sheet with babies. Top sheets can get tangled around your baby and cause them to have respiratory distress or get tangled around their arms or legs and cause your baby to lose blood circulation. Both of these scenarios are very scary to deal with. Top sheets are best avoided until your child is over two years old. If your baby gets cold in the night or seems to like the feeling of being covered then carefully choose appropriate baby sleepers for them to wear to bed. There are a variety of sleepers available for your baby to wear to bed. These are safe alternatives to a top sheet.

Q: Why can’t the baby have a blanket?

A: Babies should not sleep with blankets for the same reason they do not sleep with top sheets. The thicker material of blankets can be even more dangerous than top sheets. A blanket can get in the way of your baby’s airway and cause them to not be able to receive enough oxygen and go into respiratory distress. This is a very scary scenario for all parents and caregivers. No one wants to put their baby in danger. There are many available alternatives to baby blankets for sleeping. You should find your baby a cozy sleep sack or some comfortable pajamas so they can sleep soundly, comfortably, and safely.

Conclusion

Cribs are one of the top purchases that parents make for a baby nursery. Parents will worry about crib construction and versatility before purchasing. They will look into ergonomic, comfortable, and waterproof crib mattresses for their baby. For many parents, the crib sheets are an afterthought. They just go with the set that matches their nursery or whatever was given to them at the baby shower. Crib sheets should really be thought about more. The sheets on your bed help determine your comfort level almost more than the mattress itself.

Parents love to sleep in a comfortable bed with soft, cozy sheets. Babies also enjoy sleeping on soft sheets. Soft sheets help to avoid unnecessary skin irritations.  Your baby’s skin should be cared for carefully. You want to keep materials near them that are going to promote softness and luxury so your baby can be comfortable and not irritated. The crib sheets we have selected will help you make the right choice for your family.

All of the sheets we have picked for our list have multiple safety features. I bet before you had a newborn in your life sheet safety wasn’t even on your radar. What adult thinks about getting tangled up and having respiratory distress because of a fitted sheet? We don’t think about these things because we can move freely around our beds and can easily put a stray sheet back into its place. A little baby cannot do that. You must make sure that the sheets you select will stay firmly in place. All of the sheets on our list have elastic edging and are made to fit around a standard sized crib sheet. You will not have to worry about your little peanut getting tangled in these sheets.