Best Crib Sheets Reviewed and Rated in 2024
Jennifer Rea
Cribs can be a wonderful, cozy place for little ones to dream the night away, but ultimately, it is the crib sheets and covers that touches their skin. You’ll want something soft, easy to clean, safe, and possibly with a cute design. They will need to be fitted so that they won’t bunch up or slip out from under the mattress and preferably hypoallergenic. Manufacturers have created some excellent crib sheets that come in an assortment of designs, colors, and styles that are perfect for your infant. This beneficial buying guide highlights the best-rated and the most-reviewed of these items that customers love and are recommending to others online. Take a look at our top ten crib sheets, curated specifically for the best night’s sleep a baby could possibly want.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 44 hrs of research
Covered with whimsical colorful designs
Fits most crib mattresses of standard size
Made of high-quality jersey knit material
Helps prevent skin infections, irritations, and rashes
Has an elastic edging to keep it in place
10 Best Crib Sheets Reviewed
1. Brolex Stretchy Fitted
Covered with whimsical colorful designs
Fits most crib mattresses of standard size
Made of high-quality jersey knit material
Helps prevent skin infections, irritations, and rashes
Has an elastic edging to keep it in place
Some buyers found the material a little slippery
The elastic came apart for a few people
Covered with whimsical colorful designs of elephants and whales, the Brolex Stretchy Fitted Sheet is perfect for both boys and girls. It fits most crib mattresses of standard size and is made of high-quality jersey knit material that is super-soft. This lovely material helps prevent skin infections, irritations, and rashes since it is not harsh to the tender skin of the infant. It can be machine washed and dried, plus the terrific sheet will remain in place during use. The mattress topper has an elastic edging, so the bed is easy to make and is comprised of a mixture of polyester and spandex fabrics to make it comfortable to handle.
Read moreComfort
Babies love soft fabrics to sleep and nap on, so this jersey knit sheet will be a favorite. Parents love it too because it feels incredibly soft to the touch. Softness equals comfort for the relaxed infant.
Ease of use
As a fitted sheet, this item could not be any easier to use. you simply place it on the mattress and wrap the elastic edges over the corners of the crib mattress. It can be machine washed to make it super simple to care for, as well.
Design
The cute design of elephants and whales in a colorful pattern makes this sheet an adorable one for the baby. It is perfect for both girls and boys and a multitude of nursery themes and hues.
Value
The fabrics used to create this wonderful crib sheet make it valuable for the infant in terms of comfort and prevention of skin problems. Because it is a jersey knit, it will be one of the softest sheets you can buy.
2. Burt's Bees Thin Stripes
Available in fourteen different colors and designs
Made of 100% GOTS certified, organic cotton
Whole bottom edge is fully encased with elastic
Material is like a favorite t-shirt in softness
Ring-spun and combed for softness and durability
Some buyers said their sheets had a mild odor
Was too small and tight-fitting for a few people
Available in fourteen different colors and patterns, this Burt’s Bees Thin Stripes sheet has a snug and safe fit with the extra stretch in the premium elastic. This wonderful sheet will not creep off the mattress because of the extra material that overlaps on the edge bottom combined with the elastic perimeter. Made of 100% GOTS certified, organic, breathable cotton fabric that is terrific for the infant’s porous and thin skin, it fits standard mattresses of most toddler beds and cribs. The whole bottom edge of the sheet is fully encased with the elastic edging for the best fit. The terrific material is just like a favorite t-shirt in softness, as it will not irritate sensitive skin. It is ring-spun and combed for softness, durability, and washing without pilling.
Read moreComfort
Because it feels just like t-shirt material, your baby will love sleeping and napping on this sheet. You will also adore touching it to put it on the mattress for your little one to enjoy.
Ease of use
Fitted sheets are very easy to place on the mattress of either the crib or a toddler’s bed. It simply catches around the corners and all of the sides with the complete perimeter of elastic and extra fabric on the bottom.
Design
Not only is this wonderful sheet made to be very accommodating to sensitive and delicate skin, but it also has added security built in to keep it safely on the mattress at all times.
Value
Although this is one of the pricier sheets because of its high-quality, you will enjoy how long it lasts and its incredible durability. It is a fantastic value for the cost when it comes to longevity.
3. Kids N' Such Premium
High quality crib sheet designed to fit most crib and toddler mattresses
Features a pack of two sheets
Includes elastic band to create a secure fit
Easy care instructions with machine washable sheets
Soft and comfortable jersey knit cotton for ultimate comfort
Provides a super tight fit
Colors fade over time with machine washing
Crib sheets provide a soft surface to lay your little one on. It is important that they are able to provide a restful and comfortable place without it causing irritation or any interruption to their sleep. This set of crib sheets is able to provide that and more. The high-quality crib sheets are a great price and give the level of comfort that the little ones need.
Read moreComfort
Crib sheets have to be comfortable and these crib sheets have provided the level of comfort that little one requires and parents want. They have been constructed from lightweight cotton that features a jersey knit feel. It is a premium quality cotton blend that is perfectly created the level of comfort that you searching for.
Ease of Use
Each of the two crib sheets that come in this set has an elastic band that goes completely around the sheet on the underside. This gives the crib sheet a universal fit that allows it to be able to fit most crib and toddler bed mattresses on the market. While the crib sheet cannot prevent your little one from making a mess, it can provide a great fit that can easily be removed and machine washed. The easy-care and great fit make this set of soft crib sheets the new go-to set.
Design
Designed to give parents peace of mind these sheets fit just about any crib or toddler mattress, plus come in a set of two. Each of the pockets on the sheet is able to accommodate a 9-inch thick mattress. Not only do the sheets fit great, but they also have a great feel too. They have been created from a jersey knit blend of cotton that provides your little one with a super soft and silky smooth sheet to rest upon.
Value
Crib or toddler bed sheet is something that should always come in a pack of two because when you need one you need another. This set of crib sheets not only comes in a pack of two, but they are also created from a premium blend of cotton materials with a jersey knit to be soft and comfortable.
4. M & Y Fitted 3-Pack
Is a three-pack with different designs and colors
Fabric is cozy, breathable, and soft
A cotton jersey knit that is hypoallergenic
Elastic band is long-lasting and durable
Has nine-inch pockets on the corners
Some parents did not like the overall quality of the material
Ripping occurred for a couple of buyers
This three-pack of sheets have different designs and color patterns in a cotton jersey knit that is hypoallergenic. Designed for girls because of the pink coloration, the superb fabric is cozy, breathable, and soft and free of harmful substances. It will fit snug around standard toddler and crib mattresses since the elastic band is of high quality. The sheet stays firmly in place and is simple to put on, plus it can be machine washed and dried. The elastic band around the perimeter is long-lasting and durable to withstand many washings. It will not even come loose from the mattress when the child moves in the bed because it has nine-inch pockets on the corners to keep it snug.
Read moreComfort
Just like many other sheets that we highlight on this page, this set too is made of jersey cotton knit that is super soft and highly comfortable. This marvelous material will keep the child from sweating because it is so breathable.
Ease of use
Fitted sheets, like this one, are so easy for parents to place on the mattress of the toddler or the crib. With the simple elastic band around the edge, it just slips over the corners and around the bottom.
Design
You get three different colored sheets in this fantastic set that is designed for girls in shades of pink. This way, you will always have one ready to use that is clean and dry for the bed.
Value
No harmful substances were used in the creation of this sheet set to become a hazard for the child. The tender skin of babies should not be exposed to toxic fabrics, and with this item, they will not.
5. American Baby Company
Choose from thirty-eight different colors
Made of jersey knit cotton fabric
Matches any bedding and nursery theme
Has deep pockets on the corners of nine-inches
Fits mattresses five-inches thick the best
Can fit too loose on the bed
Only has elastic on the corners says parents
Choose from thirty-eight different colors and four package sizes for this outstanding sheet product from the American Baby Company. Made of jersey-knit cotton fabric, it fits regular toddler and crib mattresses well and is made for both boys and girls. Exceptionally comfortable just like a t-shirt, this item has colors and designs that will match any bedding and nursery theme. There are deep pockets on the corners that are nine-inches across, and the strong elastic trim covers the whole edge of the sheet. It can be machine washed and dried, plus it fits a mattress that is five-inches thick the best. This terrific item is made by a long-standing company that offers superior value and quality with their products.
Read moreComfort
Jersey knit of cotton fabric seems to be all the rage for sheet and bedding products. It is ideal for babies because of their extra-tender skin and possible skin sensitivity to various types of materials.
Ease of use
Slipping a fitted sheet on a mattress is one of the easiest household chores to do. You do not have to worry about tucking in the edges and corners because it fits perfectly as it is for a snug form.
Design
You will have a hard time deciding which colors to choose with this incredible color selection. There are thirty-eight various hues to match your nursery and other bedding pieces perfectly.
Value
The many colors, soft stretchy fabric, and the big corner pockets make this sheet one of the best on the market. You will be very satisfied with the performance of this item in keeping your child safe and comforted.
6. Arrows & Stars 100% Premium Jersey
Award winning pack of crib sheets design for comfort
Features two pack set of crib and toddler mattress sheets
Includes deep pocket design (9 inches)
Safety is priority with 360 degree band of elastic to keep sheet snug and secure
Amazing design with easy care wash instructions
After washing sheet curls around the edges
Blended cotton material can have pilling after lots of use
These are award-winning crib sheets that not only are super soft but are amazingly cute. They are not another set of those super thin and scratchy crib sheets. They are created to be smooth and soft providing that special little one in your life with a comfortable and cozy sleeping surface. Each set comes with two different patterned sheets and will match with just about any décor.
Read moreComfort
The high-quality sheets have been created from premium cotton and feature lightweight cotton with a jersey knit that feels great and looks super cute. Each of the sheets has been developed to create a surface that is breathable. This level of comfort has been created to a level of comfort that far outperforms other crib sheets on the market.
Ease of Use
Placing a crib sheet on a crib or toddler mattress can be a struggle, but with these sheets, you will not have to struggle anymore. No more tugging and pulling to make the sheet fit. These sheets feature a deep pocket design with 9-inch pockets. They are sure to fit any crib or toddler mattress with ease.
Design
When these crib mattresses were created they were designed with safety in mind. Unlike many other sheet sets on the market, safety is the number one priority of this company. They have designed these sheets with an elastic band that goes completely around the base of the sheet. It has a 360-degree band that keeps the sheet in place and secure all night long.
Value
The company has a top priority and that priority is making sure that the customer is happy and their little ones are safe. They have a 100 % hassle-free return allowing you to return the sheets in you are not in love with these sheets from day one. The two-pack design also makes the deal even sweeter.
7. Tillyou Microfiber Silky Soft
Breathable and hypoallergenic
Free of harmful pesticides and chemicals
Has deep corner pockets of eight inches
All four sides have the elastic band
Quick-drying and fade-resistant material
Has a loose fit on some mattresses
A few people complained of a rubber smell
Breathable and hypoallergenic, this Microfiber Silky Soft Sheet works well on toddler and crib mattresses and is great for both girls and boys. Made of 100% brushed extra-fine microfiber weave fabric, it is offered in twenty-three solid vibrant colors and is silky smooth and soft with a luxurious feel. This high-quality and safe product is free of harmful pesticides and chemicals and meets all CPSC safety standards. It has deep corner pockets of eight inches, plus all four sides have the elastic band for securing it to the mattress. Quick-drying and fade-resistant, this superb product can be machine washed and dried for simple cleaning.
Read moreComfort
Created from a microfiber material and not a cotton knit, this amazing sheet is silky and soft to the touch. Your infant will like the feel of this brushed fabric that is breathable and hypoallergenic.
Ease of use
Even though all of the sheets on this list are fitted sheets that fit snug on mattresses, they do not all have the same type of fit. This one has deep pockets on the corners that are eight inches for tight control of movement.
Design
Almost any nursery or bedding design can be matched well with the huge assortment of colors available for this item. There are twenty-three hues to pick from of the most vivid solid coloration.
Value
Being high-quality, safe, and hypoallergenic, this wonderful bedding item is durable and long-lasting for years of comfortable use. You will appreciate the sturdiness and build of this sheet for your baby’s bed.
8. Cuddly Cubs Jersey Knit Cotton
Cotton is combed and ring-spun
Clean, hypoallergenic, and pre-washed
Elastic band encases the whole edge
Has ten-inch pockets in the corners
Material gets softer with each wash
Fabric was thinner than some buyers expected
Stains were a problem for a couple of parents
This excellent product is a two-pack of fitted sheets made of a soft 100% jersey-knit cotton fabric. One pattern is a gray and white stripe and the other is a gray and white design of cute cartoon lambs. The color and design are great for both girls and boys to fit toddler and crib mattresses well. Breathable and cozy, they ensure all-night comfort for the infant as the cotton is combed and ring-spun for softness and durability. Clean, hypoallergenic, free of pesticides, and pre-washed, the material gets softer with each wash. These lovely sheets can be machine washed and dried with dirt and stains washing away quite easily. The overall fit is snug and secure with the elastic band encased around the complete edge of the sheets. They have ten-inch pockets in the corners that are deep, so the sheets will not come unfastened from the mattresses even with infant movement.
Read moreComfort
Combed and ring-spun cotton is what makes these incredible sheets for infants so cozy and comfortable. Perfect for any season and climate, they will be the highlight of the baby’s day to nap and sleep on.
Ease of use
Getting softer with each wash, these terrific sheets will make you quite pleased with this purchase. They come to you pre-washed already to be very soft and supple but get better with age and wear.
Design
Gray stripes and cute lambs are the patterns of these fantastic set. It is perfect for both genders of babies because of the gray neutral color and simple cartoon design that will suit any décor.
Value
A set of two sheets gives you the added flexibility and comfort of being ready with a clean and dry sheet all the time. Use one and keep one ready to care for the baby at all times.
9. Tillyou Cotton Flannel
Available in seventeen pastel colors
Made of soft chenille material
Construction of three panels
Deep pockets are nine inches
Secure and safe with the all-around elastic
Did not fit on mattress well for a few buyers
Some people reported a chemical smell
Available in seventeen pastel gorgeous colors for girls, this cotton flannel sheet is made of soft chenille material that is very comfortable for the infant. It has a construction of three panels of 100% polyester that is velvety soft for a fit that is smoother than regular jersey-knit cotton sheets. The deep pockets are nine inches for a fit that is secure and safe with the all-around elastic on the edges. This excellent item works well with most crib mattresses of standard size and can be machine washed and dried for easy care.
Read moreComfort
Unique to this list of soft sheets for babies is this item made of a comfortable chenille fabric. You will love touching this sheet material yourself because it is so luxurious and cozy smooth.
Ease of use
It is simple to put this sheet on the crib mattress because it is designed to fit perfectly to the dimensions. Made just for crib mattresses, it will be snug and form-fitting for the best safety and comfort.
Design
Choose from seventeen lovely soft pastel hues for your little girl’s bed with this exquisite sheet product. You will certainly be able to match any nursery or bedding pattern with this incredible assortment.
Value
With all-around elastic, deep corner pockets, and chenille material, you will be so glad that you bought this item for your child. it is a valuable product for the price as it is so comfortable and eye-catching.
10. Touched by Nature
Offered in thirty colors and patterns
Great for both girls and boys
Is a set of two fitted sheets
Ideal for standard crib mattresses
Has strong elastic all around the edge
Can possibly shrink after washing
Some people received the wrong items
Great for both girls and boys, this Touched by Nature sheet product is offered in thirty colors and various cute patterns. One sheet is a solid neutral color and a general pattern while the other has an adorable printed animal cartoon design. This product is a set of two fitted sheets that are ideal for standard crib mattresses. There is a strong elastic all around the edge of the sheets, so they will fit the majority of toddler mattress models too. This wonderful set would make a perfect gift for new parents or a nice present at a baby shower.
Read moreComfort
Made of soft cotton fabric, both you and your infant will love the comfortable feel of this sheet set. Both pieces will become softer with each wash as the fibers are lessened of their stiffness.
Ease of use
It will be easy for you to always have a clean and dry sheet at the ready with this superb set of two items. They fit snug and safe on the toddler or crib mattress to make your baby comfortable as he or she sleeps and naps.
Design
You get the flexibility of using different sheet patterns with this lovely set of various designs. One day use the cartoon design and the next to go with the solid color for a change of appearance.
Value
Purchasing two sheets in a set is always a smart buy because you need clean sheets all the time for a baby. Spills and accidents come easily when raising an infant, so the two sheets is a terrific value.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Comfort
Our first and most important criteria are that the crib sheets we selected be comfortable against your baby’s sensitive skin. No parent wants to take their well-rested baby out of the crib to find irritated skin from a rough sheet. Comfort is key with little babies, they are new to the world and came from a place of maximum comfort. In order for your little one to get the best sleep possible they must have the highest comfort and safety levels possible. The softness of your crib sheets can positively affect your baby’s sleep. Use a soft crib sheet and both you and your baby will be pleased with the comfort provided.
Ease of Use
These items are easy to put on and easy to remove, plus they go on a crib mattress the same way they go on a traditional mattress. Just pull the elastic around the mattress corners and you are ready to help baby settle down for some quality rest time. One big issue with fitted sheets is that they have a tendency to slip out of place with extended use. After a few days of getting into and out of bed a corner might shift off. This is not the case with the crib sheets on our list. They are all sized to perfectly fit a standard-sized crib mattress. These products have elastic edging and corner stitching to help them stay in place even with the wiggliest infants.
Design
You will love the many patterns, colors, and fabric styles of these sheet products listed here. Most of them have a huge assortment to choose from to best match your nursery décor or bedding patterns. Some of these are just for girls or boys, but the majority of the items are perfect for either gender with their neutral colors and cute designs. The construction of these products is of the best quality to fit the mattress of the crib or toddler bed well and stay on with a snug fit. They are made to last a long time and be durable and dependable to your needs of caring for your child.
Value
Made of the softest fabrics with all-around elastic and deep pockets in the corners, these sheet items have great value for the parent of a baby. Add to these features the wonderful selection of patterns and colors, and you have some terrific products to fit the crib mattress for a comfortable nap or bedtime. These are simple and easy to care for because they go on so quick and easy and can be washed and dried fast in a machine. Fitted sheets for cribs are the best solution to outfitting the baby bed because they are so easy to care for and use.
Comfort Ease of Use Design Value 
For many parents, the crib sheets are an afterthought. They just go with the set that matches their nursery or whatever was given to them at the baby shower. Crib sheets should really be thought about more since the sheets on the bed help determine the comfort level almost as much as the mattress itself. Remember that there is an option of buying a pack n play sheet that you can carry with you.
Parents love to sleep in a comfortable bed with soft, cozy sheets and so do babies. Soft sheets help to avoid unnecessary skin irritations. You want to keep materials near them that are going to promote softness and luxury so your baby can be comfortable and not irritated.
Other Factors to Consider
Safety
All of the sheets we have picked for our list have multiple safety features. Because of the threat of SIDS and other hazards for infants in cribs, it is important that the sheets and covers for babies be on properly at all times. You must make sure that the sheets you select will stay firmly in place. The elastic edging ensures a snug fit around a standard-sized crib sheet. You will not have to worry about your little one getting tangled in these sheets, as long as they are properly managed daily for wrinkles and folds that can occur naturally from wear and use.
Durability
The strong materials and durable elastic around the edges make these sheet items so durable and long-lasting for the parent. With each washing, they will get to be softer than before and will possibly have a better fit than when they were first received. You can expect to keep and use these superb products for many years. Even when the child grows to be a toddler, they can be used on those bigger beds, as the elastic and material will stretch to fit those bed sizes too.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: Can't my baby just sleep on the crib mattress?
No, your baby should not sleep on a bare crib mattress. Crib mattresses are made of a waterproof plastic-type material that can be harmful to a baby’s sensitive skin. If you lay your baby directly on the crib mattress they could stick to the plastic material and damage their new skin.
q: How many crib sheets do I need?
You will want to have between four and six crib sheets for your baby. You need this many crib sheets because you will have to have extras around when you are washing dirty sheets.
q: Why do crib sheets have elastic?
Crib sheets need to be able to stay securely on the crib mattress. This is for the safety of your baby. The elastic on the edges of the crib sheet holds the sheet in place as your baby sleeps and moves around their crib.
q: How do I clean a crib sheet?
You will clean a crib sheet the same way that you clean a regular bed sheet. If you are using specific gentle baby detergent, then wash your crib sheets with that detergent. Otherwise, crib sheets can be washed in the washing machine and dried in the dryer. Check your sheet’s care tag for specific water temperature and dryer heat setting.
q: Where is the top sheet?
You should not use a top sheet with babies. Top sheets can get tangled around your baby and cause them to have respiratory distress or get tangled around their arms or legs and cause your baby to lose blood circulation. Both of these scenarios are very scary to deal with. Top sheets are best avoided until your child is over two years old.
q: Why can’t the baby have a blanket?
Babies should not sleep with blankets for the same reason they do not sleep with top sheets. The thicker material of blankets can be even more dangerous than top sheets. A blanket can get in the way of your baby’s airway and cause them to not be able to receive enough oxygen and go into respiratory distress. This is a very scary scenario for all parents and caregivers.
Sources
- , Sleeping like a baby: how to buy the right bedding, Online Article
- , How to Choose the Best Crib Sheets for Your Baby, Online Article
- , Crib Sheet Tip/Trick to Save Time and One’s Sanity, Online Article
