10 Best Organic Crib Mattresses Reviewed in 2024
Stacey Joseph
Purchasing a crib mattress can be a trying task for new parents, especially if you are looking for a very specific type of mattress. Organic mattresses are free from harmful chemicals, toxins, and processes that make them bad for the environment and the child. Both the mattress and the cover are constructed of natural materials such as soy, bamboo, cotton, or even coconut husks. Manufacturers have created some excellent products that are perfect for parents who do not want to expose their children to the substances used in regular crib mattresses. We are excited to showcase these outstanding products for your shopping experience. Here are the best organic crib mattresses in 2019.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 20 hrs of research
Hypoallergenic, waterproof, and lightweight
Uses renewable soybeans for the foam-core
Terrific for infants and toddlers
Cover has lock-stitch binding
Tested for chemicals that are flame retardant
-
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core
-
Newton Hypoallergenic Non-Toxic
-
Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness
-
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer
-
Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring
-
LA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1
-
Serta Perfect Deluxe Fiber Core
-
Emily Natural Eco-Wool Two-Sided
-
Dream on Me Pocket Coil Mini
-
NapYou Dual Comfort 100% Waterproof
10 Best Organic Crib Mattresses Reviewed
1. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core
Hypoallergenic, waterproof, and lightweight
Uses renewable soybeans for the foam-core
Terrific for infants and toddlers
Cover has lock-stitch binding
Tested for chemicals that are flame retardant
Was not wide enough for some cribs
Can be a bit noisy sometimes
Hypoallergenic, waterproof, and lightweight, the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress uses renewable soybeans for the foam-core and is perfect for infants and toddlers. It is comfortable and firm, uses Cert-PUR-US foam, and is tested for chemicals that are flame-retardant.
Read moreComfort
This great product does not have any flame retardants of TCEP, TDCPP, PBDES, formaldehyde, mercury, lead, or phthalates. The durable cover is stain-resistant and waterproof. It has lock-stitch binding to keep liquids from getting through but prevents dander and dust from clinging. Certified by Greenguard Gold for a healthy product, it is lightweight, so handling is easier. It has a design of square corners to fit regular cribs well.
Design
You will not have to worry about flame retardants or harmful chemicals being involved in the making or substances of this wonderful item. It is free from the usual problematic substances that can cause health issues. The lovely cover for this incredible mattress is waterproof and easy to handle. It also has a lock-stitch binding which keeps dander and dust from becoming ingrained into the fibers and staying there.
Value
Having a below-average price, this ideal organic mattress derives its value from the omission of flame-retardant materials, using soybeans for the core, and having a highly-functional cover.
2. Newton Hypoallergenic Non-Toxic
Hypoallergenic, washable, and non-toxic
Has the Breathe-Thru Technology
Regulates temperature to prevent overheating
Cover unzips for easy removal and washing
Made to fit all cribs of regular size
Cover is bad with lint after washing in a machine
The surface of this cover is scratchy
Ideal for toddler bed and cribs, the Newton Baby Crib Mattress is hypoallergenic, washable, and non-toxic. It has Breathe-Thru Technology which decreases CO2 rebreathing and suffocation, plus improves the quality of sleep for the child. This advancement also regulates temperature to prevent sweaty backs and overheating with its award-winning design.
Read moreComfort
Recommended by doctors and certified by Greenguard Gold, it does not have any allergens, glue, latex, springs, or foam. It is completely recyclable and has the ideal amount of firmness for the best comfort. The core is made of 90% air and 10% polymer that is food-grade, and the cover unzips for easy removal and washing. Made to fit all cribs of regular size, this is one of the most outstanding mattresses on the market currently.
Design
This wonderful mattress is super-cushy because it is made of mostly air. The core is just a small percentage of polymer material and the rest is air for the most comfortable feeling similar to floating. Breathe-Thru Technology keeps the infant from breathing in its own CO2 and from suffocating when sleeping on his or her stomach. It allows in extra air that other mattresses and covers do not.
Value
This crib mattress has the highest price of all the listed items. It has the great features of being Greenguard Gold certified, having the Breathe-Thru Technology, and including a zippered thick cover.
3. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness
Fits all regular-sized toddler beds and cribs
Has dual firmness for toddlers that infants
Foam is made with plant oils that are sustainable
Free of phthalates and is hypoallergenic
Lightweight to make sheet changes easy
Not waterproof said some parents
A few people received stained products
The cover of the Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress is made of organic cotton. This amazing product fits all regular-sized toddler beds and cribs and has dual firmness that is softer for toddlers than infants. Infants need a firmer mattress than toddlers because of the breathing issues and their rapid body development.
Read moreComfort
Made of lightweight foam that is six inches thick, it is Greenguard and CertiPUR-US certified. The durable foam is eco-friendlier because it is made with plant oils that are sustainable. Free of phthalates and hypoallergenic, it is lightweight to make sheet changes easy.
Design
Crib mattresses that have dual sides are terrific to grow with the child. one side is firm for the infant, and the other is softer for the toddler. Their sleeping needs are met wonderfully with this type of mattress.
The two certifications that this ideal product has meant that it is very safe for your child to use. you can rest assured that they will not be breathing in or coming into contact with any substances that will harm them.
Value
The price for this great item is below the figured average. It is valued for having an organic cotton cover, being dual-sided, and having the certification of Greenguard and CertiPUR-US.
4. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer
Has a dual surface for toddlers and infants
Free of flame-retardant and toxic chemicals
Made of stretch-knit medical-grade fabric
Resistant to dust mites and bedbugs
Tested for performance, safety, and durability
The overall quality was disappointing for some parents
Mattress sinks in the middle said a few people
Hypoallergenic, waterproof, lightweight, and antimicrobial, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress has a dual surface for toddlers and infants. This ensures that each stage of life gets the type of support it needs from the mattress. Instead of having to purchase another mattress when the child grows, you just flip this one over.
Read moreComfort
The softer toddler side will provide a softer surface for a comfortable sleep. Free of flame-retardant and toxic chemicals, it is made of stretch-knit medical-grade fabric that has tight seams. Resistant to dust mites and bedbugs because of the SafeSewn Seams, it is easy to clean with a wet cloth or sponge. This safe item has been tested for performance, safety, and durability rigorously.
Design
The dual surface of this incredible product lets y99u use it longer into the toddler years. It is more flexible on the toddler side for a more relaxed sleep but is firm on the infant’s side to give the stability needed for proper body structure. The tight and safe seams of this mattress will prevent the problems of dust mites and bedbugs from bothering your child. they will not have anywhere to hide and live, so they will not form in this product.
Value
The cost for this crib mattress is above the figured average. It derives its value from having a dual surface for toddlers and infants, being free of toxins and chemicals, and having tight seams to ward off potential problems.
5. Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring
Includes 120 innerspring heavy-duty coils
Has convoluted layers for extra comfort
Made without flame retardants
Has a lightweight construction and vents
Features square corners for a snug fit
The firmness of the infant side did not please some parents
A few people were confused about which side was which
Certified Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US, the Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib Mattress has a non-toxic and waterproof cover that resists stains and moisture. It includes 120 innerspring heavy-duty coils for support and comfort and has convoluted layers for extra comfort.
Read moreComfort
Included is a cotton cover on the softer toddler side, and the infant side has a cover of waterproof vinyl. Made without flame retardants, it has a lightweight construction and vents for air and features square corners for a snug fit in the crib.
Design
The covers are even different on each side of this ideal mattress. The toddler side has a soft cotton cover, and the infant side has a waterproof vinyl cover to prevent liquids from being absorbed. The technology of dual-sided crib mattresses is a wonderful idea. The infant grows so fast that they would not get much use from it if it were not changeable for the toddler to enjoy as well.
Value
This terrific mattress has the lowest cost of all products here. Its value is derived from the dual sides for toddlers and infants, the cotton and vinyl covers, and the snug square corners that fit well.
6. LA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1
Made from resources that are renewable
Has memory foam on one side for comfort
Both sides have a polyester blend layer
The waterproof cover prevents dust mites
Ideal for those with sensitive skin
Some parents think this item is flimsy
Might not be waterproof as stated
The LA Baby Natural IV Triple Zone 2 in 1 Soy Foam Crib Mattress is made of soy foam borders and core that are high-density for additional support. Constructed from resources that are renewable, it has memory foam on the side of the infant and includes air vents for freshness.
Read moreComfort
Both sides have an added layer of a polyester blend for super comfort. The waterproof cover has a barrier against dust mites and is hypoallergenic. The bamboo cover is made of spandex, microfiber, and bamboo, plus it stretches and conforms to the different cores on the two sides. Ideal for those with sensitive skin, the bamboo is thermal-regulating. A lock stitch is sewn into the cloth binding to prevent moisture and seam-splitting to make it more durable and longer-lasting.
Design
Both the borders and the core of this item are constructed using soy. This is a renewable resource that is free from toxins and chemicals, making it completely safe for the sleeping child. The excellent bamboo cover for this wonderful mattress is waterproof and stretchable. It has spandex material in it to stretch in place on either side of the mattress for the infant or the toddler.
Value
With a below-average price, this amazing product has dual surfaces, a stretchable bamboo cover, and a lock stitch in the cloth to make the item more durable and waterproof.
7. Serta Perfect Deluxe Fiber Core
Double-sided for longer use
Waterproof vinyl cover makes care easy
Polyester fiber core is both firm/supportive and comfortable
Comes in “Deluxe” and “Supreme” options for a more luxurious experience
A few customers had quality control issues and received mattresses that dipped in the center quickly
The Serta Deluxe Fiber Core Crib Mattress really is, as the company suggests, the “perfect start.” These non-toxic foam mattresses are made in the USA and come Greenguard certified. They’re waterproof and stain-resistant. They’re also free of phthalates and lead. All have passed CPSIA testing, so you can rest as peacefully as your little one, knowing that they’re sleeping safe and sound.
Read moreComfort
A polyester fiber core makes this foam mattress ideal in terms of both support and comfort. It’s just firm enough to support your infant or toddler, while still being cushy and comfortable enough that they’ll drift off into dreamland in no time at all. The square corners ensure a snug fit so the crib won’t bunch or move and cause baby any discomfort or harm.
Design
Lightweight, this baby mattress makes changing the sheets easy. It measures 27.5” wide x 52” long x 6” high. The waterproof vinyl cover is built for longevity and makes maintenance and cleaning a breeze. It’s double-sided so you can flip the mattress when it’s time for your little one to move into a toddler bed.
Value
This is currently one of the two most budget-friendly options on our list. It falls significantly short of the median price point on our guide but still maintains a high standard and a strong record of customer satisfaction.
8. Emily Natural Eco-Wool Two-Sided
Is dual-sided for toddlers and infants
Certified Greenguard Gold
Uses organic cotton that is GOTS-certified
Cover is quilted and made of natural eco-wool
Includes 150 innerspring coils
Some people said this item is too small for a crib
A few buyers claim it sags in the middle with the child
The Emily Crib Mattress is dual-sided for toddlers and infants and includes 150 innerspring coils. Certified Greenguard Gold, it is a handcrafted item that uses organic cotton that is GOTS-certified. The cover is quilted and made of natural eco-wool and does not contain any polyurethane foam.
Read moreComfort
The dual functioning sides give your child a long time to enjoy this mattress because of the different surfaces and support. you will appreciate not having to purchase another mattress for the toddler bed so soon too. This wonderful product is free of lead and non-flammable.
Design
This fabulous item is Greenguard Gold and GOTS-certified. This ensures that your child is sleeping on the safest materials that are free from toxins and chemicals that could harm them. With the innerspring coils on the inside of this wonderful mattress, you know that you are getting much more than just a large piece of foam. It will support the weight of the child for the most comfort while sleeping.
Value
The cost of this item is above-average. It is valued for its Greenguard Gold certification, the dual sides for toddlers and babies, and the sturdy innerspring coils for firmness and comfort.
9. Dream on Me Pocket Coil Mini
Firm pocket coil
Lock-stitch binding to prevent unraveling
Wire perimeter keeps mattress border from sagging
Greenguard certified
Covered in noisy plastic vinyl
The Dream on Me Pocket Coil Mini Mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified so you know you’re truly investing in the best for your little sleepyhead. Made from pocket coil, this mattress fits mini/portable cribs and is hypo-allergenic. This organic baby mattress is firm, comfortable, made in the USA, and tested for lead and phthalates. This mattress is a safe place to lay your infant down for the sweetest of dreams.
Read moreComfort
Infant mattresses need to be firmer than most of us would deem comfortable in order to help support their growing little bodies. This baby mattress features full border wires to keep the perimeter of the mattress from sagging. Airflow pockets keep this mattress fresh for hygiene and to avoid uncomfortable smells.
Design
Lock-stitch binding ensures none of the edges will unravel and cause a choking hazard. It’s made with pocket coils and Dream on Me manufactures several different sizes to fit various crib styles. This particular mattress is a Mini, meaning it fits portable cribs just perfectly. It measures 24” x 38” and is 3” high. Cute sleeping little cherubs spread out over the mattress to create a soothing pattern.
Value
This is the least expensive item on our list, probably due to the fact that it’s not a standard crib mattress but rather intended for a mini.
10. NapYou Dual Comfort 100% Waterproof
Features a 100% waterproof cover of cotton
Has a contouring layer of memory foam
Cleans easily with the waterproof cover
Fits most cribs and toddler beds
Made with CertPUR-US foam
Some babies did not like this mattress
The cover can be a bit difficult to remove and put on
The NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress is dual-sided, meaning that toddlers sleep on the soft side and infants seep on the firm side. It has a 100% waterproof cover of organic cotton that is breathable and removable and a contouring layer of memory foam.
Read moreComfort
This amazing product provides the ideal posture for the back and neck of the toddler and cleans easily with the waterproof cover. It fits most cribs of standard size and toddler beds. Made with CertPUR-US foam for safety, it can be machine washed.
Design
The waterproof cotton cover for this incredible mattress is easy to clean and remove. It is breathable and comfortable for the child to sleep on, plus is made with organic materials. You can use this mattress for the first few years of your child’s life. It has a side for the infant and the other for the toddler. It fits both sizes of bed types as well as it is fully compatible.
Value
The cost for this terrific item is below the figured average. It has the great features of being the standard size for cribs and toddler beds, having dual sides, and including a waterproof cotton cover.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
Comfort
Comfort for children is very important
Featuring just the most-reviewed and the best-rated products of a category, our helpful buying guides show you only what customers loved the best and the ones they would certainly buy again. We research all of the product details, customer feedback, and data that we can find for these top items, so you can make the most informed decisions as to which ones are perfect for you and your family. Our guides are unique in that we blend facts and customer comments to give you the full picture of each item. We tell you what is great and what is not for the most honest and trusted review. The crib mattress with the highest rating is the NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress with a perfect score from buyers. The one with the most reviews is the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress. All feature items are terrific, but these are the most excellent.
Design
Good design leads to comfort
Mattresses for regular cribs must be a specific size to the inch or they will be a safety hazard for the child. Even a gap of just an inch or two here and there is dangerous for babies. They can get caught in these small spaces and hurt themselves or smother. The two-finger rule is used to determine if a crib mattress is good enough to stay in place. If you can place two fingers side-by-side in the space, then the mattress is not safe for the child. all of these featured mattresses should be the ideal size for regular and standard cribs.
Value
Price Range will impact on quality
We list the best qualities and features of each product in the individual Cost and Value sections that make up the value of each one. You will also see there the indication of the current cost. Because online prices change frequently, we do not give the exact costs here. We feel it is best to give qualitative descriptions of the prices as compared to the calculated average of all items. These are listed as average, below-average, and above-average. There are no average-priced items in this category of organic crib mattresses, so other than the highest and the lowest-priced products, you will see the other descriptions. The mattress with the highest cost is the Newton Baby Crib Mattress, and the one with the lowest cost is the Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib Mattress. These items differ in materials they are made of, the size and thickness, and the firmness.
Comfort Design Value 
You want to sleep as peacefully as your child but there are always an infinite number of things to worry about, especially with infants. To give yourself some peace of mind, make sure you’re informed about the safest sleeping conditions for your sweet pea. There are generally two types of crib mattresses: spring and foam. Neither is inherently better than the other. You’ll want to check your mattresses for chemical odors, buy a firm mattress, and watch that it doesn’t sag or unravel over time. Firm mattresses can help prevent suffocation and SIDS, as well as give your infant a supportive place to properly grow.
Newborns typically sleep about 8 hours throughout the day and another 8 throughout the night. If you’re a new parent, this may not seem right given how often they wake but this is due to the small size of their stomach, which causes them to stir every few hours to eat. Don’t worry; as they grow so do their tummies and soon they’ll be sleeping soundly throughout the night!
Other Factors to Consider
Age Range
Most of these terrific mattresses can be used for a toddler after the infant grows up. This is because they are dual-sided with different materials on each side. The softer and more flexible side is for the toddler who appreciates a cover of memory foam or a soft cotton cover. Toddlers need the softness in a mattress to be comfortable. Infants, on the other hand, require a firm mattress for their body support. they need to lay on a surface that will support their spine and not give when they are facing into the surface. This would cause breathing problems for the baby.
Materials
The materials that these ideal mattresses are constructed of are organic, natural, and eco-friendly. Whether it is soy, cotton, coconut, or bamboo, your child will experience the best and softest materials in crib mattresses that manufacturers have to offer. Because the child’s tender skin and face come in contact with this bedding surface so often, it is well worth the extra cost and effort to get mattresses made with the excellent substances. You will certainly need such products for children that have very fair skin or have skin allergies to regular mattress materials.
Frequently Asked Questions
q: What organic materials do they contain?
The organic materials vary from product to product, but in general, they contain coconut husks, cotton, soy, and bamboo in varying measurements. These are mostly on the covers, with the mattresses having foam substances for support. they are free of chemicals and toxins to give the baby or toddler a safe place to put their head, face, and tender skin while sleeping. These are ideal for those with very sensitive skin or allergies.
q: Are these mattresses all the same size?
Yes, they should all be the same width and length to fit most standard and regular crib sizes. Use the two-finger rule to determine if they are the correct size for your crib when you receive them. It is better to return a crib of inappropriate size than to use it and be sorry later on. It is not safe to place a baby in a crib where the mattress does not fit snug against the sides.
q: Does it matter how thick these are? Are they different in thickness?
Yes, some of these mattresses are five inches, while others are six inches. The standard is five inches, but as long as the mattress fits snug in the crib, the thickness is not the most important aspect. A thicker mattress would be harder for the parents to handle and flip, but to the baby, it makes no difference.
q: Some of them are described as dual mattresses, what does that mean?
A dual-sided mattress means that one side is ideal for infants and the other side is good for toddlers. Toddlers need a softer mattress than infants do because they are heavier and need more cushioning when they sleep. Infants, on the other hand, require more firm support from their sleeping surface for their quickly developing spine and bone structure. The harder surface for the baby does not promote a breathing hazard for them as they sleep on their stomachs either.
q: Do any of these come with a protective cover to keep them waterproof?
Yes, most of these items do have waterproof covers, especially for the infant side if it is a dual-sided mattress. A few of them have waterproof covers that come off and can be placed on either side of the product. We made a notation if the covers or mattresses are waterproof in the summary sections of each one. If the mattress does not come with a cover, then the mattress itself is most likely waterproof.
q: Are these good for any age of infant and toddler to sleep on?
If the product does not specifically say that it is a dual-sided mattress, then it is only for infants and babies. The ones that are dual-sided have two completely different sides for the two ages of a child. The infant side is not flexible or soft because it must be supportive of their soft body structure. Infants need the support of this stiff surface to aid their spines and breathing. Because they must sleep on their stomachs for safety, there is a chance with a soft surface of the baby’s face being pushed into the fabric. This causes the possibility of smothering. The toddler side is softer and usually has a layer of soft cotton or memory foam. This make sit more comfortable for the older child.
Sources
- , How to Choose a Crib Mattress for Your Nursery, Online Article
- , Your Guide to Choosing an Organic Crib Mattress, Online Article
- , Crib Mattress Buying Guide, Online Article
