to top 10 table

10 Best Ice Cream Makers Reviewed in 2019

last updated Jun 03, 2019

Ice cream is a favorite treat for pretty much anyone these days. While you can find ice cream almost anywhere from a grocery store or to a local scoop shop, what’s better to have around your house than your own ice cream maker? Not only will it be a favorite family memory, but also you’ll be able to make dairy-free ice-cream with any of your favorite flavors, add your favorite candies and always have a yummy treat on hand without having to leave the comfort of your home.

Making homemade ice cream adds, of course, a personal touch. You can use almond, soy, or goat milk to make your ice cream. If you or anyone in your family has allergies, you won’t have to worry any longer about an allergic reaction as you will know every ingredient that went into the batch.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 17 hrs of research

icon
Cuisinart ICE-21R
96.7/100 our score
Flavors
97
Ease of Use
96
Value
97
Cuisinart ICE-21R
Why is it better?

Fast

No need for salt and ice

Durable

Multi-use

Easy cleanup

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Cuisinart ICE-21R
Test Winner: Cuisinart ICE-21R
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
22
Researched Sources
Hours Researching
17
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
18
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Flavors Ease of Use Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.7
Flavors
97 %
Ease of Use
96 %
Value
97 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$42.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96
Flavors
96 %
Ease of Use
96 %
Value
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$70.69
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.7
Flavors
96 %
Ease of Use
95 %
Value
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$117.25
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Flavors
95 %
Ease of Use
95 %
Value
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$33.40
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Flavors
94 %
Ease of Use
95 %
Value
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$28.00
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Flavors
94 %
Ease of Use
94 %
Value
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$232.35
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Flavors
93 %
Ease of Use
93 %
Value
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$120.34
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Flavors
93 %
Ease of Use
93 %
Value
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$37.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Flavors
91 %
Ease of Use
92 %
Value
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$249.99
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90
Flavors
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (18.08.19)
Amazon Link
$220.54
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Cuisinart ICE-21R
  • Cuisinart ICE-30BC
  • Yonanas 978
  • Hamilton Beach 68330N
  • Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE
  • Cuisinart ICE-100
  • Cuisinart ICE-70
  • Nostalgia ICMP400WD
  • Whynter ICM-200LS
  • White Mountain PBWMIME612-SHP
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Expert Interviews & Opinions
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Ice Cream Makers Reviewed

1. Cuisinart ICE-21R

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.7
Cuisinart ICE-21R
Amazon Link
Flavors
97
Ease of Use
96
Value
97
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$42.99

Fast

No need for salt and ice

Durable

Multi-use

Easy cleanup

Noisy

The Cuisinart ICE-21R has snagged our top spot! This is a premium ice cream maker is for ice cream connoisseurs. You will not be disappointed with the many features that this ice cream maker offers you. Its sleek design will look gorgeous on your counter.

Read more

Flavors

It comes in pink, fuchsia, red, and white to match any decor. This machine can also whip up a fantastic batch of frozen yogurt or sorbet. This Cuisinart is a crowd pleaser and sized just right for personalization. You can make a smaller batch for a personalized pint or create a large batch for a dinner party or kid’s sleepover. This updated model has a new paddle style that will get you your favorite sweet treat in under 20 minutes. You can make up to 1 ½ quart of pure yumminess with this device. It is the perfect size for your family. The lid is transparent and includes a large spout for adding ingredients and watching the magic happen. This is a great activity to do with the whole family!

Ease of Use

This is one heavy duty ice cream maker. It will get you ice cream in no time. It also makes sorbet and frozen yogurt. If you'd prefer to have a cold icy beverage this machine has your back. Everyone in your group will be pleased that you made the choice to buy this ice cream machine.

Value

This ice cream maker is a great value. You will get years of delicious treats for a mid-level price. Just store the included bowl in the freezer, keep ingredients on hand, and watch your savings add up!

2. Cuisinart ICE-30BC

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96
Cuisinart ICE-30BC
Amazon Link
Flavors
96
Ease of Use
96
Value
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$70.69

Sleek design

Large spout for adding ingredients

2 qt capacity

Quick turn around

Heavy duty motor

Must hand wash the freezer bowl

Coming in at number two is the Cuisinart ICE-30BC. It is a bit bigger than its predecessor on the list. This is one versatile machine that doesn't require you to spend all day churning to get a perfect consistency for your dessert.

Read more

Flavors

It is sleek and stylish enough to be left out on the counter. You can make all members of the family happy because this little dynamo makes ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet. Just make sure to save room in the freezer or invite over your friends for all of the extra ice cream. This ice cream maker has a two-quart capacity that is perfect for most recipes. It will whip up your preferred treat in as little as 25 minutes. When your machine is done doing all of the work just rinse the bowl with some soapy water and pop it back in the freezer for your next batch! This machine is super easy to clean so you can quickly enjoy your treat.

Ease of Use

The self-locking lid has a large spout for adding ingredients without making a huge mess. Little Johnny will have a blast putting his favorite candy or fruit into his ice cream with this machine.

Value

This sleek and durable machine will have you creating cool goodness for years. It comes in at the middle range of prices for our top ten list, so it is a great value.

3. Yonanas 978

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.7
Yonanas 978
Amazon Link
Flavors
96
Ease of Use
95
Value
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$117.25

Dishwasher Safe

Super fast

Allergy free

Unique

Quiet

Only makes soft serve

Not a traditional ice cream maker

The Yonanas 978 Elite has earned number three on the list of top ten ice cream makers. This unique frozen treat maker doesn't need the regular ingredients that you would need in your typical home ice cream maker.

Read more

Flavor

If you live a dairy-free or vegan lifestyle then this is the perfect choice to make yummy sweet treats. Maybe your family is trying to make healthier choices or you are starting your journey in a sugar-free lifestyle; this is the perfect frozen treat maker for you. This treat maker only needs frozen fruit to make a yummy sorbet style dessert. Just freeze your fruit in 1-inch chunks and feed them through the chute. It comes equipped with a plunger to push the fruit through. Make sure your ready to eat, because dessert will be ready in just a few short minutes. Take a trip to the local farmers market or fruit stand and pick out your fresh food to make dessert for tonight. Yummy!

Ease of Use

The machine puts your sweet treat right into the bowl so you can eat immediately. The health factor of skipping all of the added ingredients makes this a great choice for a young family or a family working to make healthier choices. Also, all of the removable parts are dishwasher safe. The quick convenience of this frozen treat maker will have you eating dessert in no time.

Value

This machine is near our top price point. Its value becomes apparent the first time you make a cool treat in minutes and clean up is a breeze.

4. Hamilton Beach 68330N

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Hamilton Beach 68330N
Amazon Link
Flavors
95
Ease of Use
95
Value
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$33.40

Efficient

Functional

4 quart capacity

Easy to clean

Lightweight

Does not work well with lots of mix-ins

Hamilton Beach’s Automatic Ice Cream Maker is at number 4 on our list. This machine has a large capacity to make enough ice cream for friends and family. You can use this device whenever the desire for a sweet treat hit you.

Read more

Flavors

No need to freeze any parts, just add cold ingredients and have plenty of rock salt and ice on hand. This is the perfect ice cream maker for your backyard barbeque or family get together. This machine will produce up to four quarts of ice cream! It consists of an outer bucket, an inner bucket, a paddle, a lid, and a motor. These pars are all easy to clean, either wipe them off or wash with warm soapy water. Your ice cream, frozen yogurt, custard, sherbet, or gelato will be ready to eat in 20 - 40 minutes. This is an older style ice cream maker and requires that you pack ice and rock salt around the interior bucket to freeze the ice cream. This ice cream maker is a great addition to any family.

Ease of Use

The best thing about this ice cream maker is that it comes with an included recipe bok so you can start making ice cream right away.

Value

This machine is of great value. It comes in at the lower end of our prices for this list. You will get your monies worth with the first few batches of delicious creaminess.

5. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE
Amazon Link
Flavors
94
Ease of Use
95
Value
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$28.00

Easy to clean

Easy to transport

4-quart capacity

Recipes included

Functional

The motor is not intended for use with lots of mix-ins

Our number five ice cream maker is the Nostalgia ICMP 400 Blue. This blue bucket is as cute as it is efficient. It has a larger capacity than some other makers on our list.

Read more

Flavor

The bucket comes with a handle for easy carrying and a quick cool canister. The Nostalgia Blue will make a hot summer day more bearable by giving you a cool treat quickly. This device will make both ice cream and sorbet. It has a locking lid to keep all parts in place while the motor is going. The lid to the interior canister is see through so you can watch the magic happen. The exterior bucket is easily accessible for adding additional rock salt and ice while the ice cream is churning. You won’t be disappointed with this cute blue bucket.

Ease of Use

The convenient carry handle makes this ice cream make easy to transport from your pantry to the backyard or to a friend’s house. This is the perfect ice cream maker for an impromptu get together.

Value

This maker is at the low end of prices on our list. The portability and overall usefulness of this machine make it a great value.

6. Cuisinart ICE-100

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Cuisinart ICE-100
Amazon Link
Flavors
94
Ease of Use
94
Value
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$232.35

Fully automatic

Sleek

Digital display

Auto shut off timer

10 minute stay cool function

Need a separate container for storage

Our number six pick is the Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor. This is a top of the line home ice cream maker. You do not need to add ice or freeze and additional parts. Just plug it in and add your ingredients.

Read more

Flavor

It can quickly make authenticly styled frozen treats. The digital display makes it easy to use. This high-quality ice cream maker will make you and your family delicious ice cream for years to come! The ICE-100 comes equipped with a commercial quality compressor. It also has a second paddle specifically for creating gelato. This machine can make your Italian ice cream dreams come true without leaving your home! It has a 1.5-quart capacity to make plenty of your favorite treat. The 60 minute LCD backlit countdown timer will let the kiddos (and parents) know exactly when the ice cream will be done. The mixing bowl had a convenient handle for easy removal. This device’s lid is see through so everyone can peek in on the mixing action. This top of the line home ice cream maker will keep your family entertained for many a hot summer, and maybe a few cool winter nights.

Ease of Use

The best feature on this ice cream maker is the 10-minute cooldown feature that will keep your ice cream cool in the machine after it is done mixing. Now you don’t have to worry about standing around for the last few minutes of the mixing cycle. This machine will bring you a lot of yummy goodness!

Value

This machine takes the guesswork out of making ice cream, no more worrying about ice to salt ratios or if the bowl is cold enough. The cost is high end, but the peace of mind that comes with its ease of use is well worth the cost.

7. Cuisinart ICE-70

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Cuisinart ICE-70
Amazon Link
Flavors
93
Ease of Use
93
Value
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$120.34

Auto shut off

Multiple speed settings

Countdown timer

Integrated measuring cup

Quick

The lid is hard to attach

The Cuisinart ICE-70 is our number seven pick. It can make a variety of frozen treats to please everyone in your family. It is the perfect size to make dessert for a small gathering or to last a few days.

Read more

Flavors

It comes equipped with a timer and convenient spout for adding ingredients with less mess. This ice cream maker will help your family make fun memories for years to come nice flavors.

Ease of Use

This machine has a two-quart capacity. The lid is clear so you can watch it churn away at your frozen treat. In 20- 40 minutes you can have delicious frozen yogurt, ice cream, sorbet, or gelato. It has three settings and multiple speeds to make the perfect treat. It comes equipped with a countdown timer so you know exactly when your dessert will be complete and ready to eat!
The freezer bowl can be rinsed out and stored in your freezer after each use so you can make ice cream any time!

Value

This device falls into the mid-range for pricing on our top ten list. It is money well spent because you will be able to make multiple types of frozen treats in a timely manner.

8. Nostalgia ICMP400WD

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Nostalgia ICMP400WD
Amazon Link
Flavors
93
Ease of Use
93
Value
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$37.99

Great design

Easy to clean

Clear lid

Recipes included

Real wood outer construction

Uses rock salt and ice cooling method

Our number 8 pick is the Nostalgia ICMP 400 WD. This ice cream maker will bring you back to summers on Grandpa’s back porch waiting for the ice cream to finish churning. It has an outer wooden bucket that looks like something out of the 1950s.

Read more

Flavor

Great flavor maker. This ice cream maker is ready to help you continue the family tradition of summers on the back porch. Add in your favorite ingredients and spend a warm summer afternoon reminiscing over summers past.

Ease of Use

This machine is super easy to clean, with a plastic lined outer bucket and a quick to cool aluminum interior bucket. The sturdy outer bucket is made of real wood and the motor locks into place. The 4-quart capacity makes this ice cream maker perfect for a party or to make a yummy dessert to snack on for the week. Don’t forget some handy storage containers, you will have plenty of leftovers. This ice cream maker is big enough to feed a party and reminds us of times past. It is the perfect combination of modern and old-fashioned.

Value

The price point for this ice cream maker makes it a great value. You can have all of your memories come rushing back to you for a mid-level price.

9. Whynter ICM-200LS

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Whynter ICM-200LS
Amazon Link
Flavors
91
Ease of Use
92
Value
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$249.99

No parts to freeze

Auto shut off

LCD time and temperature display

Easy to clean

Extended cool feature

Noisy

Whynter ICM-200LS gets our number nine spot. This device does not need any pre-freezing! This premium machine offers a variety of premium options for your convenience. Use the built-in timer to keep your dessert making on track. Your only worries with this machine are to have the proper ingredients on hand.

Read more

Flavor

You will be ready to make a yummy frozen treat in less than an hour from preparation to eating.

Ease of Use

You can make multiple batches back to back! The compressor keeps this 2-quart machine cool, so you don’t have to use your freezer to hold ice cream maker parts. When you are all done making your yummy dessert just give the removable bowl a quick hand wash and you are ready for your next batch. Use this machine to make the best ice cream, gelato and sorbet recipes you can find. Your whole family will thank you! The company will send you secret recipes on request, and they even included an ice cream scoop with purchase!

Value

This Whynter device falls into the high end of our pricing. The value is in the compressor. When you have a compressor motor you don’t need to worry about pre-freezing any parts, you just pour in your ingredients and enjoy your ice cream.

10. White Mountain PBWMIME612-SHP

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90
White Mountain PBWMIME612-SHP
Amazon Link
Flavors
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$220.54

Large capacity

Beautiful construction

Durable

Triple action stirring

Commercial grade motor

Very large

Our list ends with the White Mountain 6-quart ice cream maker. This large capacity ice cream maker is a crowd pleaser. It has solid construction and a powerful motor. It has a patented stirring method that creates great ice cream every time.

Read more

Flavor

The flavor is great. The wooden outer bucket is sturdy and reminds you of older model ice cream makers from summers past. This ice cream maker won’t disappoint. Now go grab your neighbors and some family members for an afternoon of ice cream sundaes.

Ease of Use

This machine is full of benefits! It comes equipped with a 12,000 rpm commercial grade motor gives your ice cream a super smooth consistency. The dasher (stir stick) is made of coated cast iron for years of use. This durable ice cream maker will still be working hard when your kids go off to college! It only takes 20-40 minutes to make a batch of yummy goodness. Grab one of these quickly so you can start making memories with your loved ones. It had a gorgeous white pine bucket and durable interior parts to last and last. The interior bucket is stainless steel to keep everything extra cold. This is one device you will enjoy for a while.

Value

The cost of this machine is at the higher end of our list. It is well worth the money you will spend. The parts are super durable and it comes with a 5-year limited warranty for peace of mind.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Ease of Use

The last thing anyone wants to do is to have a difficult cleaning task after making such a wonderful treat. You won’t have to worry about that with these ice cream makers–all of them are easy to clean. All you will need to be able to do is remove the bowl and detach the stir sticks for easy cleanup. Every one of our machines on our list is easy to disassemble after a sweet day of ice cream making.

With any new appliance, there is always a learning curve. We wanted to make sure that each ice cream maker on our list was easy to use and had easy-to-follow instructions. Mostly, all you have to do is to chill your ingredients and your interior container (freezer bowl or canister) and you should have great, tasty ice cream each time. They are all electric so all you have to do is push a button and watch the machine do work. No more having to crank your afternoon away waiting for ice cream.

Flavors

Nobody wants to spend their entire day waiting for ice cream. Once you decide on what flavor to make, you’re going to want to eat it quickly. We made sure that these specific ice cream makers will be done churning in an hour or even less than that. Nobody likes to wait! This way you can get to the best part, eating, quickly. Most of the machines on our list come, of course, with recipe guides that will include times and some of them even have auto-stop motors that stop when the ice cream reaches specific consistency. Timing is everything and when you have a family, especially one with young children, waiting for ice cream is not an option.

Value

If your ice cream maker comes with its own freezer bowl, store it in the coldest part of your freezer and you’re going to want to make sure that the freezer temp is at 0 degrees Fahrenheit. If the bowl is always frozen then you’re always ready to make ice cream! Don’t put the freezer bowl in the dishwasher for it will ruin the freezing liquid and will no longer keep your ice cream frozen. Prior to making ice cream, you’re going to want to make sure the base is in the refrigerator for a few hours so that you can have the best consistency.

Remember homemade ice cream is free from stabilizers and other additives used to keep store-bought ice cream super-thick. Keep in mind also that homemade ice cream will have a creamier consistency. Of course, it will usually thicken once it’s set up for a few hours in the refrigerator. Most importantly have fun! Don’t forget to experiment with your new machine and find some unique recipes that you and your family will love. You’ll be surprised by all of the possibilities waiting for you.

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Flavors
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Ease of Use
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Parents, Did You Know?

Look for a product which offers value and good performance and has a good set of features. Shop and search until you find the ideal home product, there are many options.

Parents, Did You Know?

Consider flavors to avoid repetition, choose a product that can operate and produce a nice selection of flavors to stimulate taste and enjoyment. Some products can allow you to blend and create a choice of flavors. Do some research to see what is the best product for your ice cream making aims.

Other Factors to Consider

Capacity

The capacity of the ice cream maker was one of the things we considered when coming up with our list. The smallest capacity machine we have makes individual bowls of dessert and the largest of them is six quarts. You can pick a device that will cater to each person, event, or your family, depending on your personal preference.

Durability

When it comes to ice cream, your maker should be able to withstand tons of use. Each maker on our list is made of durable materials and built to last. You’re going to want to make sure to read the instructions before adding in a lot of extras to your ice cream. These unique machines are created to stir ice cream and can get easily clogged up if you add too many goodies at the wrong time.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What type of ice cream maker should I buy?

a:

The type of ice cream maker you choose depends entirely on your personal preference and your budget. If timing is your main concern a compressor-style machine will be your best option; it has the quickest start-to-finish time available. If budget tops your list of concerns, then go for a double bucket ice cream maker that requires ice and rock salt for cooling. If you want to avoid the mess of salt and ice and still want a quick treat, then go for the frozen bowl-style of a machine. All of these machines will give you quality ice cream, you just need to decide what options will work best to meet your personal needs.

q: How long will it take to make my ice cream?

a:

The length of time it takes to make your ice cream will depend on many factors. The recipe you choose, the temperature of your machine, and the speed of your motor are the top things that will affect timing. The machines on our top 10 list can make ice cream in as little as 15 minutes when prepped correctly. Make sure to check your user’s guide to ensure that you are using your machine correctly.

q: Is homemade ice cream better than store bought?

a:

Homemade ice cream can be made to your exact preferences. Personalized taste and texture will always win! Sure you can get really good premium brand ice cream, but it still has additives and preservatives. If you make your ice cream you know the exact ingredients. Knowledge is power.

q: How do I clean my ice cream maker?

a:

Clean the bucket or bowl of your ice cream maker immediately after use using warm (not hot) soapy water. Wipe down the outside of your plastic or stainless steel machine with appropriate food-safe cleaner. Use a clean cloth to wipe down the outside of wooden ice cream makers. Check your manufacturer’s directions for proper motor cleaning and maintenance.

q: Are there recipe books for homemade ice cream?

a:

The majority of the machines on our list come with recipe guides. There are also tons of guides available commercially. Be warned that not all motors are created equally. Adding in lots of extra goodies can cause issues with lower power motors. Check your user’s guide for advice. Remember you can always stir in goodies after your ice cream is made like they do in popular commercial ice cream and frozen yogurt shops.

q: How does an at-home ice cream maker work?

a:

All ice cream makers stir specific ingredients together with a long paddle in a cold container. The cooking methods, type of paddle, and the motor will vary based on who made the machine. Usually, when using a compressor or freezer bowl-style machine, the ice cream maker is put together and turned on before ingredients are added. Then you slowly add the ice cream base and watch the magic happen. Once the ice cream starts to set up you may start to add in some special extras like crushed cookies or candies. Once these are fully incorporated and the ice cream is frozen thoroughly, it should be done. If you want a harder consistency place the batch in the freezer for a few hours.

Sources

  1. Kristen Hicks , The Sweet Tooth’s Guide to Buying an Ice Cream Maker, Buyer's Guide
  2. The Good Housekeeping Institute, How to Buy an Ice Cream Maker, Shopping Tips
  3. Jessica Harlan, Anatomy of an Ice Cream Maker, Informative Article
  4. Staff, ICE CREAM / YOGURT MAKERS, Product Information
Baby Jogger City Mini
Baby Jogger City Mini
Retail Price: 400 USD
  • 12 days
  • :
  • 22 hours
  • :
  • 51 minutes
Our New Monthly Giveaway
Your email will be safe with us. We will never spam you.
Past winners & details