to top 10 table

10 Best Piñatas Reviewed & Rated in 2019

last updated Jun 19, 2019

Pinatas are pretty much a birthday staple these days. Kids love getting to try their hand at opening fun, colorful pinatas to unload a treasure trove of candy and toys. Whether you’re interested in a pull-string pinata or a classic pinata, you deserve a range of options to find the style that best fits your family. Below, we’ve gathered ten of the best pinatas on the market. Stock up on goodies to fill them with and get ready for some fun!

In a Hurry? The test winner after 30 hrs of research

icon
Hello Kitty
96.5/100 our score
Design
97
Entertainment Value
95
Ease of Use
98
Price Range
96
Hello Kitty
Why is it better?

Well made

Pull string option

Cute Hello Kitty Design

Sturdy

Can hold about 2.5 pounds of candy

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Hello Kitty
Test Winner: Hello Kitty
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
20
Researched Sources
Hours Researching
30
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
16
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Angeline Mirenda:

These pinatas are anything but a swing and a miss! In fact, they’re such a hit that we’ve had to replace four low stock or unavailable items in this round of updates. Check out our latest additions: Hello Kitty, the Ya Otta Tank, the Ya Otta Tractor, and the Blue Panda Mini Unicorns!

Sorting Options
Design Entertainment Value Ease of Use Price Range By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.5
Design
97%
Entertainment Value
95%
Ease of Use
98%
Price Range
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$19.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Design
96%
Entertainment Value
94%
Ease of Use
97%
Price Range
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$20.60
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
Design
95%
Entertainment Value
93%
Ease of Use
96%
Price Range
95%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
Design
94%
Entertainment Value
92%
Ease of Use
95%
Price Range
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$15.69
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Design
93%
Entertainment Value
91%
Ease of Use
94%
Price Range
95%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$12.81
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
Design
92%
Entertainment Value
90%
Ease of Use
93%
Price Range
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$12.68
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Design
91%
Entertainment Value
89%
Ease of Use
92%
Price Range
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$13.39
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Design
90%
Entertainment Value
88%
Ease of Use
91%
Price Range
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$12.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.5
Design
89%
Entertainment Value
87%
Ease of Use
90%
Price Range
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$22.99
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Design
88%
Entertainment Value
86%
Ease of Use
89%
Price Range
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.07.19)
Amazon Link
$27.75
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Hello Kitty
  • Mermaid Pull String
  • Fire Engine
  • Rhode Island Novelty Mini Donkey
  • Ya Otta Tank
  • Ya Otta Tractor
  • Dragon Aztec Imports Inc.
  • Blue Panda Unicorn 3 Pack
  • Reusable Party Goodie Gusher
  • Vampire Coffin Unique Industries
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Piñatas

1. Hello Kitty

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.5
Hello Kitty
Amazon Link
Design
97
Entertainment Value
95
Ease of Use
98
Price Range
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$19.99

Well made

Pull string option

Cute Hello Kitty Design

Sturdy

Can hold about 2.5 pounds of candy

Poor packaging; some pinatas arrived damaged

Small/thin fill-hole, so it takes a while to put the candy and goodies in

“Hello Kitty, hello dear friend! Your smile is pretty as a flower that’s in bloom. Love is in your heart, you feel so happy too, hey!” If this catchy little jingle rings any bells for you, you likely have a Hello Kitty enthusiast in the house.

Read more

Design

Surprise them on their birthday with their favorite Sanrio friend! The Ya Otta Hello Kitty pull-string pinata can be played with one of two ways: hit it like a traditional pinata, or use the strings at the bottom. One string will open the pinata to reveal the candy but all others are just loosely attached strings. This way you can keep the darling Hello Kitty pinata around for a few days after the party!

Entertainment Value

Pinatas are a great social activity for kids. It gets everyone together in a group and working towards the same goal. This Hello Kitty Pinata is the perfect party accessory for any feline fans out there!

Ease of Use

It’s nice to have the option of pull strings if you want to opt out of a bat or stick. Plus this pinata is, by all accounts, sturdily made and ready to party with your sweet peas!

Price Range

This pinata is pretty moderately priced and is well made. The Hello Kitty design is cute and executed with detail; you’re not getting a weird knock-off cat that looks out of proportion.

2. Mermaid Pull String

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95.8
Mermaid Pull String
Amazon Link
Design
96
Entertainment Value
94
Ease of Use
97
Price Range
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$20.60

Pull-string allows for easy release

Comes empty so you can choose the filler

Highly detailed and colorful

Large size

Perfect for beach-themed parties

It can be tough to break open with a stick

She looks like an extra from the movie Aquamarine but she's actually filled with candy. This goodie-filled mermaid is sure to bring a splash of fun to any summer-themed party.

Read more

Design

Summer parties really are some of the best, but what happens when you want to bring a little bit of summer indoors during those cold winter months? This mermaid piñata is the perfect way to add a little splash of tropical fun to your child's party. This cute little Mermaid has all the features of a traditional seafaring woman, complete with bright pink hair and a vibrant teal tail. Even her facial expression is highly detailed and she's wearing a look that's almost as if to say, "Surprise! I'm filled with goodies". At least that's what we think, anyway! The unique aspect to this piñata is that you don't actually need to whack it -- There's a pull-string at the bottom that allows kids to release all of the candy in one hard tug. Don't worry, this piñata is definitely not an easy one to pop open... The string is designed to release the goodies hiding inside only when the string is pulled hard enough at the right angle!

Entertainment Value

There are multiple ways to release all the treasures hiding inside which is great for those parents who want to put their own goodies inside. It comes empty and with two options to expose the filler inside, you'll have free reign over what's hiding inside for your little ones.

Ease of Use

This fanciful mermaid is a ton of fun and super versatile for indoor and outdoor parties as well as good throughout any time of year. It's also incredibly age-friendly since the pull-string allows for little kid participation without dealing with a bunch of kids swinging sticks and potentially injuring each other.

3. Fire Engine

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
Fire Engine
Amazon Link
Design
95
Entertainment Value
93
Ease of Use
96
Price Range
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link

Vibrantly colored

A popular theme for young kids

Can hold two pounds of candy

Larger than most products

Comes with a loop for easy hanging

It could be stronger in order to hold the maximum amount of candy

Did someone call the fire department? Because we think this decoration is on fire! It's sure to be a hit at any party, especially if you have fans of fire safety there. Firefighters are tres, tres cool.

Read more

Design

Whoa, talk about holding a fire truck's worth of candy! This brazen truck can hold up to two pounds which is much more than most parents need for one party, but it sure does allow for options. This is the ultimate in parties for little boys or even for girls who love playing with cars. The truck is incredibly detailed for being a decorative candy-holder and even features characters and a tiny dog, characteristic of old-school fire trucks. This bright red would catch any child's attention and we wouldn't be surprised if they simply won't be able to wait to tear into this vibrant rescue engine. The truck can be hung with a loop string that's found on the top and can be placed indoors or outdoors. It's the perfect addition to any party since it can hold any variety of candy you choose, included themed candies for parties and celebrations. You could even store tiny prizes in here since the weight limit is so allowing of heavier items!

Entertainment Value

This piñata is huge which means you can fit just about anything inside of it. That also means that it will be put to good use at larger parties and won't look small and inconsequential at rented halls or in large gathering rooms or spaces.

Ease of Use

The theme of firefighters is something that many kids fall in love with at a young age. It's neutral but also something that's fun, colorful, and easy enough to plan a party around. It also goes hand in hand with some popular children's television shows as well.

4. Rhode Island Novelty Mini Donkey

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.8
Rhode Island Novelty Mini Donkey
Amazon Link
Design
94
Entertainment Value
92
Ease of Use
95
Price Range
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$15.69

Set of three

Cute and colorful

Traditional style

Can be used as a decoration

Neutral for any party theme

They're somewhat small

You don't get one but three options to send candy spilling down below with this option. It's traditional, yet three times the fun.

Read more

Design

For a more traditional spin on children's birthday parties, these donkey piñatas are a perfect place to start. They're not oversized and since there are three to a set, they'd still be great for larger parties and kids can count on having three candy-holders to burst open. Each one of these donkeys is brightly colored and can be filled easily through an opening on each of the legs, making for a sturdy and solid container to hold all of your candy. They can be hung indoors or outdoors and fit with most themes, as they're neutral and traditional in design. Each donkey is attached via a streamer that runs down the center so this decorative element can also be used as a hanging decoration to add a bright burst of color or a pop of fun to any party. They're great for any age, kids or adults, and their high quality makes them the perfect option for a general game of "pop the piñata".

Entertainment Value

This is about as traditional as traditional gets when it comes to trying your best to cause a candy-filled explosion. These donkeys are adorable and are sure to incite giggles of glee when it comes time to start a sugar rush and a mad dash to see who can get the most candy.

Ease of Use

We love that these donkeys come in a set of three. You have the option for turning them into a fun decoration or you can have your kids descend on all three at once -- The more candy collecting, the better!

5. Ya Otta Tank

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.3
Ya Otta Tank
Amazon Link
Design
93
Entertainment Value
91
Ease of Use
94
Price Range
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$12.81

Durable

Fun tank design

Pull-string option

Can hold a moderate amount of candy and toys

Small fill hole, hard to find

Pull-strings don’t always work

Roll out with this awesome Ya Otta Tank pinata! If you’ve got a little one that’s all about the tank and army action these days, throw a themed party they’ll love. This tank pinata is perfect for GI Joe parties, or even Toy Story ones (think of the little green army men).

Read more

Design

It measures about sixteen inches wide, six and a half inches high, and nine inches deep. It’s a pull string pinata so you can opt out of a bat or stick if you feel that the traditional pinata customs might be a little too dangerous for a rowdy or really young group.

Entertainment Value

Pinatas can help to develop hand-eye coordination. Pull string pinatas are more about luck than athleticism or aim but they’re also more age-inclusive. Toddlers might have a hard time swinging something heavy enough to break that pinata open but even tiny tots can manage a pull string.

Ease of Use

It’s a cute, simple little tank. And if you have a child that is easily attached to their toys, you can keep the tank around for them to play with after the party as long as you’re not smashing it to pieces.

Price Range

The Ya Otta pinatas are pretty well priced. They are a little small and they take a little longer to fill (unless you cut a bigger hole), but they’re well made and will hold up under some rough play.

6. Ya Otta Tractor

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.3
Ya Otta Tractor
Amazon Link
Design
92
Entertainment Value
90
Ease of Use
93
Price Range
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$12.68

Awesome tractor design

Durable; kids will get a turn

Traditional pinata (no pull-strings)

Helps develop hand-eye coordination and motor skills

Small

The bottom is extremely durable (difficult to break, even), but top breaks off easily with the weight of the candy

Ride on in style with the Ya Otta Tractor pinata. Have a little one that loves cars? Or maybe your birthday bash is centered around farms with cute little animals and fun barnyards decorating the event.

Read more

Design

The Ya Otta tractor is a darling addition for any tots interested in vehicles or farm life. It measures roughly ten inches high, six inches wide, and sixteen and a half inches long. It’s small enough that it won’t be a hassle to hang or fill, but it still holds a decent amount of goodies.

Entertainment Value

This tractor pinata is heavy-duty on the bottom, so brace it appropriately and get ready for some heavy hitting! Pinatas can help develop motor skills, hand-eye coordination, and social skills.

Ease of Use

It’s cute and unique. Kids will be jumping at the chance to take a swing at this old tractor and plow through the candy and goodies inside.

Price Range

The pinata is small but it really is durable. Everyone will likely get a turn hitting at it as long as you brace the top properly. (Lots of families have had success with zip ties.). Given the quality, we think it’s a fair price.

7. Dragon Aztec Imports Inc.

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Dragon Aztec Imports Inc.
Amazon Link
Design
91
Entertainment Value
89
Ease of Use
92
Price Range
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$13.39

Super vibrant

Adorned with dragon-themed details

Holds up to two pounds of candy

Good for large groups

Doesn't break too easily

The green option looks more like a dinosaur

As far as the mythical and medieval go, dragons are definitely the top contender when it comes to driving home the theme. However, they are also represented in the Chinese culture as well, making this poppable party bag totally versatile.

Read more

Design

Ready to spice things up a bit? Dragons traditionally have roots in Chinese culture but this one finds its place with Aztec Imports Inc. as a fiery little dragon. In fact, the company claims you can "set the party on fire" with this dragon. While that's not something you want to do in a literal sense, it will definitely bring a sense of wonder and amusement to your child's party. When your little one walks in with their friends, their eyes will immediately widen at the sight of this crazy themed piñata, complete with tiny horns, large glaring eyes, and vibrant colors. You can choose either red or green and it's up to you to fill it with your child's favorite candies. It's a large dragon and can hold up to two pounds of candy, making it ideal for big parties.

Entertainment Value

This crazy cascading dragon holds all the magic and wonders that kids look for in that one party surprise. It'll be a crowd pleaser as well as a statement piece for any birthday party or holiday celebration.

Ease of Use

The vibrantly colored tissue paper that adorns this dragon is what makes it stand out in the center of a room. It can be used indoors or outside for a grand celebration and will have no problem taking center stage.

8. Blue Panda Unicorn 3 Pack

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Blue Panda Unicorn 3 Pack
Amazon Link
Design
90
Entertainment Value
88
Ease of Use
91
Price Range
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$12.99

Three pinatas per pack

Cute unicorn design

Durable

Traditional pinata (no pull-strings)

Small

A little tougher to break open

These mini unicorns are full of magic! Constructed with white tissue paper, these authentic mini pinatas are a fun little event for any celebration. At 5.25” by 8.7”, these little guys are extra cute and won’t take up a whole ton of space while you wait to be able to hang them.

Read more

Design

They’re strong so everyone can take a whack at them; they won’t break open super easily and leave party-goers with a turn. Shaped like little unicorns, these are sure to add some spark and pizzazz to your special day.

Entertainment Value

These traditional pinatas help promote hand-eye coordination and motor skills all while being tons of fun! Children will learn to take turns, be patient, and enjoy their spoils for good behavior and teamwork.

Ease of Use

They’re so little! That might not. Be ideal for every party, but it does give you the opportunity to set up multiple areas and have three rounds going at once, or cycle through pinatas in the same area until all party goers have a shot.

Price Range

These little guys are a great value. They’re smaller, but you’re getting three for the price of one, and they aren’t cheaply made; they’ll hold up while taking a beating.

9. Reusable Party Goodie Gusher

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.5
Reusable Party Goodie Gusher
Amazon Link
Design
89
Entertainment Value
87
Ease of Use
90
Price Range
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$22.99

Reusable for multiple parties

Eco-friendly

No need for a bat or stick

Friendly for younger kids

Eye-catching

The cardboard can tear easily if kids pull on the tabs too hard

We'll bet you didn't know that you could be so eco-friendly when it comes to party favors, but it's true. This Goodie Gusher will continue gushing goodies until it completely falls apart, which isn't likely to happen anytime soon.

Read more

Design

The beautiful thing about modernizing traditional party games and favors is that they get much-needed updates that can help in a plethora of ways. Believe it or not, this is a reusable piñata that can be strung up for multiple parties and still be used just like it was the first day you opened it. This cute little pink cylinder works in a slightly different way than most piñatas, so let us explain. For starters, there's no need for a bat or stick in order to break it open. Rather, kids will take turns pulling the little tabs found throughout its exterior in the hopes of being the one to make it rain candy. It's playfully adorned with emojis which are relevant to the current generation and make it super trendy. It's perfect for all ages but works very well for younger kids who might not be old enough to swing a bat in the hopes of hitting their piñata.

Entertainment Value

This is a nearly accident-free way of enjoying all the traditional fun that comes with swinging a bat and releasing a wave of yummy candy. It's a safe and effective way to incorporate this fun tradition into your child's party without worrying about coordination and timing.

Ease of Use

The fact that this product is reusable is one of our favorite things. Not only is it eco-friendly, but it's a great way to continuously throw parties while having a great element of fun and something kids will surely love.

10. Vampire Coffin Unique Industries

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Vampire Coffin Unique Industries
Amazon Link
Design
88
Entertainment Value
86
Ease of Use
89
Price Range
88
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$27.75

Great for Halloween

Stickless fun makes for a safer game

Can be filled with two pounds of candy

Features up to eight strings that can release candy

Spooky without being too scary

It can be challenging to fill

Stumped as far as how to provide entertainment for a Halloween party? Don't worry, we've got you covered! With candy and a bit of spook, that is. Muhahaha!

Read more

Design

There is absolutely no reason as to why candy can't come from a piñata rather than a bowl on Halloween! This vampire is super cool and just awesome enough to be deserving of your next Halloween party. It can be used any time of year for any type of horror-themed party and can be filled with up to two pounds of delicious candy. The product itself is shipped flat to save on space but is easily set up by pulling the colored strings on either side. The front of this coffin features a creepy-looking vampire that's been painted in stunning detail for something your kids will smash to bits, but wait -- They won't need to with this one! What do we mean by that? You'll notice a string coming from the bottom of the coffin. By pulling this string in just enough in just the right way, your child will be seconds away from a candy waterfall, no sticks necessary. Kids are going to have a blast taking turns pulling the string that's guarded by this eerie-looking vamp.

Entertainment Value

A stickless piñata is a safe one and we love that pulling a string is all it takes to send candy flying. It's thoughtful and inventive and definitely creates a safer environment for younger kids.

Ease of Use

We love that this vampire has been adapted to fit a specific theme and possibly even a specific holiday. It just goes to show that piñatas really can be found for any party and any celebration.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Entertainment Value

Most obviously, it's a fun game to play complete with great party favors that kids will be walking away with after playing it. However, piñatas are so much more than that. They're a means for social interaction and for getting kids involved because there's no particular skill needed in order to be the one to cover the room in candy. All you need is a good sense of direction and a lucky shot in order to be the "winner". That's the other wonderful thing about this game -- There really is no "winner", per se. Once the box is broken open and candy has spilled out, it's fair game for any around to jump in the middle and grab what they can. This is a game meant for celebration, not for competition, and that's part of why we love it so much. It will encourage kids to work together in order to achieve their goal which is, of course, getting all the candy possible!

Ease of Use

In order to determine what was "high quality" for products such as these, we needed to ensure that each piñata would last and wouldn't just explode on one hit. While there are products on here that are a bit easier to break into than others -- and have been listed as such in each summary -- there are plenty on here that provide quite a bit of a challenge. Overall, each of these items has been deemed worthy of a party and suitable for several rounds of smashing.

Design

You wouldn't be interested in something that doesn't look pretty, right? Right! That's why all of these options, whether colorful, traditional, or themed, have been evaluated based on their appearance as well. Each one came in a delightful design that we thought would be appropriate for any age, at any type of celebration.

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Design
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Entertainment Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Parents, Did you Know?

The pinata is a fun activity for both children and adults. Precaution measures to be taken before using a pinata are ensuring that guests stand in a space far away from the pinata to avoid bystanders getting hurt by the one trying to break it.

Parents, Did you Know?

Pinatas are a historical symbol in Mexico. Pinatas are found to decorate children's birthday parties primarily in Mexico, but also in the United States. They are usually filled up with candy or toys and even fruit during the Christmas season.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What is the safest way to hang the piñata?

a:

Our suggestion would be to hang it from the sturdiest tree branch you can find or in a wide doorway. Most of the smashing should take place outdoors or in a larger space in order to prevent damage or injury to others. With a long enough line (such as cable or fishing line), it can be hung in the middle as well, if the cord is attached at either end to a point in the room.

q: Where can I find tiny prizes to act as a filler?

a:

You can easily find filler products at places like the dollar store or a department store, but Amazon also has plenty of fun goodies if you search for "party favors".

q: Is this safe for all ages?

a:

Yes! This is definitely a game that is age-friendly. Our suggestion would be to go with a product that features a stickless option in order to ensure that everyone can play and that there's no risk of injury.

q: Would these be suitable for older kids as well, for example at a graduation party?

a:

Any of these would make a perfectly fun addition to any type of party. These products are timeless and ageless and are appreciated by everyone. Depending on what your filler is, they can appeal to a wide variety of age groups.

q: Is it reusable?

a:

There is only one product on our list that's reusable, and it's produced by Goodie Gusher. This can be reused as long as it holds up and doesn't take on too much wear and tear and it's also stick-free for risk-free fun.

q: How far should kids stand when someone is taking a turn?

a:

This is a great and important question. In order to maintain a safe distance, we'd recommend positioning kids in a circle at least four to five feet from the person who is taking a swing. It's suggested that you steer them in the right direction before giving them the okay, but every child should be alert and aware so that they can move, should the swinging become too far off-course.

Sources

  1. Unknown Author, History of the Piñata, Informative Article
  2. Diane Selkirk, The Mysterious Origins of the Pinata, Travel Article
  3. Justin Cecil, Interesting facts about the piñata, Blog Article