Best Nipple Creams for Breastfeeding Mothers Reviewed in 2018

Not only does breastfeeding increase the level of bonding between you and your baby, but it also provides several health benefits to you both as well. However, breastfeeding can be difficult for some women and many women experience sore, cracked, or bleeding nipples. As you begin to breastfeed, it is normal to have some pain and tenderness. Don’t ignore the pain, it is not something that you have to put up with in order to feed your baby. In fact, ignoring the pain will only make it worse. Finding a good nipple cream will provide you with the relief you need to enjoy feeding time with your baby. As with many baby products, the market is cluttered with nipple creams, balms, and salves. We created a list of the 10 best nipple creams to help narrow down your search. As you read through our list, pay attention to the ingredients of each cream. The size of the bottle may also help you make a decision. Will this be a bottle be for your nursery or do you want to carry it with you throughout the day? Whichever cream you decide on, we’re confident that after applying a few dabs, you and baby can comfortably enjoy feedings again.

Last Updated:
By Amanda Milewski:

Although breastfeeding is the best first nutrition for babies, it doesn't come without difficulty and discomfort at times. We have recently updated this list to include a couple of new products that can alleviate some of that discomfort as new mothers get used to the nursing process.

Our Top 3 Picks

Motherlove Organic Salve
  • Motherlove Organic Salve
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • All-natural
  • Cruelty-free
  • Price: See Here
Lansinoh Lanolin Natural
  • Lansinoh Lanolin Natural
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • BPA free
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Price: See Here
Earth Mama Organic
  • Earth Mama Organic
  • 4.3 out of 5
    Our rating
  • High-quality
  • Non-GMO
  • Price: See Here

Criteria Used in Evaluation of the Best Nipple Creams for Breastfeeding Mothers

Breastfeeding a baby can come with several unique challenges for the mother of a newborn that she may not have anticipated. Unfortunately, nipple irritation is one of these factors, so a quality nipple cream to use during the breastfeeding stage of a child’s life is essential. There is a reason that women are given nipple creams at baby showers and why hospitals also provide them. However, there are several different kinds of nipple creams on the market and a new mother may find it hard to narrow down the search to find the one that will work for her. When creating our list, we wanted to look for factors that a new mother would also want to take into consideration and this created the criteria for our list.

Soothing and healing

Finding a nipple cream that is soothing to the sore breast is definitely important. The cream has to be able to relieve the pain that a woman is experiencing. It also needs to be able to give relief to skin that is irritated and also needs to help promote healing.

Protection

This is another reason why women use nipple cream. In many ways, these are similar to the diaper rash cream we purchase for the baby because it provides a protective barrier shield. This protective barrier will lock out the moisture that causes more irritation to the skin.

Lightly Scented or Unscented

On average, most women don’t want a nipple cream that has a strange odor or a heavily perfumed scent. Not only is this not what the product is designed for but it also can cause issues to the baby who may not like the odor of the cream. So, a quality nipple cream should either have a very light scent or be unscented.

Safe/Nontoxic

When it comes to nipple cream the safety and toxicity of ingredients were taken into consideration. The ingredients in the cream have to be safe and nontoxic. They had to have been tested and proven not to be harmful to the skin. Also, most importantly, the ingredients should have proven not to be harmful if ingested by the infant. If the nipple cream is nontoxic, a new mother doesn’t need to worry about whether she should remove it before breastfeeding.

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How long does a woman need to use nipple cream?

A: Generally, a woman should only have to use a nipple cream for no more than two weeks when first breastfeeding. This is mainly due to the fact that the nipples need to get used to the process. Some women, however, may need to continue to use one a bit longer.

Q: Can breast milk be used as a way to heal the breast?

A: Yes, breast milk can actually be used to help heal the nipples. A woman can basically work some of the breast milk into the breast after nursing. It can also be used in conjunction with a quality nipple cream such as the ones we have listed here. The thing to remember though is the make sure that nipples are dry before applying the nipple cream.

Q: Is nipple cream containing lanolin really safe to use?

A: There has been much concern over nipple creams containing lanolin. There have been reports that these contain pesticides. Also, there are those who believe that lanolin-based products such as nipple creams can cause cancer.

Now, it is understandable that new mothers would be concerned by this. But there is another side to this argument that contends that the lanolin used in nipple creams goes through a proper filtration process. The few nipple creams on our list above that contain lanolin certainly have been properly tested to be safe.

These creams also have received rave reviews online for not just being beneficial to the mother but not being harmful to a newborn. One important concern to take into account when choosing a nipple cream that contains lanolin-based ingredients is that if a woman is allergic to wool, she should avoid these products since lanolin is sheep’s wool.

The best advice for a new mother who has concerns about lanolin-based nipple creams, is to choose instead one of the many organic natural alternatives that work just as effectively.

Q: Does nipple cream expire?

A: Like any over-the-counter product that has been opened, yes nipple cream does expire. Usually, they have a shelf life of up to one year.

If the product comes with a date of expiration stamped on it great, if not then look at the date on your calendar as to when the cream was opened and take the time to write the date down on the label of the nipple cream. This will tell you that one year to this date the cream should no longer be used.

Q: Can nipple cream be used on other areas of the body?

A: There is some proof that nipple cream that contains lanolin is also good to use on chapped lips. It takes only a small amount placed on the lips but turns out that this actually works effectively.

Also, as stated above, it also can be used for diaper rash on the baby. The cream will actually create a protective barrier and also help the skin to heal. These types of creams can also work as a moisturizer for extremely dry, chapped skin.

Q: Can nipple creams cause an allergic reaction?

A: As stated above, even if these creams are natural, there is always the possibility that a woman could be allergic to certain ingredients such as lanolin and even the organic ingredients used.

So, it is important to either find the ingredients for the product online or to even read the product while in the store to see the ingredients listed. If a woman knows she is allergic to something that could be in the product she should avoid using it.

Q: Are these nipple creams really safe for baby?

A: Even with all-natural organic ingredients, there is still always a concern of allergic reaction. Another thing to keep in mind is that some vitamins, such as E and A, may not agree with a baby’s delicate digestions, which could be ingested while breastfeeding. At that age, the breast milk provides all the nutrition the baby needs where vitamins and minerals are the concern.

These are things to keep in mind, but it’s also not advisable to continually wipe off the nipple cream before breastfeeding because this can cause more damage to the breast. So, a concerned mother could consult the obstetrician about what nipple cream they would recommend and feel isn’t going to cause any issue for the baby.

Q: What if the soreness persists or gets worse while using a nipple cream?

A: It is always best to consult with your obstetrician or primary care physician if the breast doesn’t seem to be getting any relief from the nipple cream. If the soreness or chapping persist, this could be the result of another underlying problem.

Another good piece of advice is to get their input about the best nipple cream to use while breastfeeding. Some of these could cause allergic reactions in the nursing mothers and even the newborns, and a physician could be of help in determining which one is best-suited to your needs.

Sources

  1. Admin, 13 great uses for nipple cream, Online Article,
  2. Stephanie B says , Exclusively Pumping and Nipple Pain, informative article,
  3. Teresa Pitman , 10 ways to prevent and treat sore nipples, Online Article,
  4. Sioned Hilton, Nipple care for breastfeeding mums , Online Article,
  5. Sarah Hosseini, Can I Use Nipple Cream If I'm Breastfeeding?, Informative Article,